2002
2003
2004

  • Quick note on Goldberry and River-woman  <NZ Strider>  [10/15 @ 22:25]  (2/6)

  • (side discussion) In the house of Tom Bombadil - Closer than we know?  <Ataahua>  [10/15 @ 20:52]  (3/14)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #12: The contented log  <Lottelita>  [10/15 @ 19:59]  (8/12)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #11: "Into his quiet sleep"  <Lottelita>  [10/15 @ 19:57]  (4/9)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #10: "A change came over his dreams."  <Lottelita>  [10/15 @ 19:49]  (5/8)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #9: "A dream without light"  <Lottelita>  [10/15 @ 19:41]  (7/21)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #8: "Heed no nightly noises."  <Lottelita>  [10/15 @ 19:28]  (3/12)

  • Thanks so much for the great answers to my question about elf relationships.  you guys are great!  (No Text)  <summertime>  [10/15 @ 17:06]  (1/1)

  • way OT: to test the water  <sundering_c>  [10/15 @ 15:38]  (4/6)

  • this is off topic from Tolkien, but it's about mythology...  <Rider Of The Rohirrim>  [10/15 @ 13:30]  (2/3)

  • who is the old man  <bilbojohnstone>  [10/15 @ 10:28]  (2/9)

  • Druedain  <Moiraine>  [10/15 @ 10:19]  (1/3)

  • Interesting thought popped into my head  <Inferno>  [10/15 @ 7:40]  (8/12)

  • Three of the nazguls are black numenoreans. Says who ????  <mordorer>  [10/15 @ 4:29]  (1/2)

  • uh...a question about the relationships amoung elves  <summertime>  [10/14 @ 16:55]  (5/26)

  • Does Tolkien ever explain exactly how or who gave the rings to the various leaders?  (No Text)  <thiefbaggins>  [10/14 @ 14:01]  (1/4)

  • Denethor and the Palantir  <Luthien's Mama>  [10/14 @ 13:27]  (2/4)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #7: “… was it just chance …?”  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 13:23]  (10/24)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #6: A long and merry meal  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 13:11]  (5/7)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #5: “He is.”  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 12:37]  (8/23)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #4: Fair Lady Goldberry  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 12:03]  (7/61)

  • Taking up the Tolkien mantle.  <irpacynot>  [10/14 @ 9:58]  (7/17)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #3: The house  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 8:29]  (4/13)

  • By the way, thanks to Thelvina Finduilas...  <Reverend>  [10/14 @ 7:42]  (6/7)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #2: I hate this chapter!  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 7:37]  (5/11)

  • In the House of Tom Bombadil #1: I love this chapter!  <Lottelita>  [10/14 @ 7:33]  (13/24)

  • Does Galadriel get ALL her power from Nenya alone?  (No Text)  <Galadriel's apprentice>  [10/14 @ 7:14]  (2/2)

  • Upcoming Online Discussion:  Famer Giles of Ham  <notlost>  [10/14 @ 6:12]  (1/1)

  • Curious,  if you're still collecting...  <Reverend>  [10/13 @ 21:50]  (1/1)

  • Wormtongue  <entish freedom fighter>  [10/13 @ 21:01]  (1/3)

  • Glamdring and Orcrist  <Arod the Swift>  [10/13 @ 20:49]  (3/8)

  • I was reading “The New Shadow” recently,  <Kimi>  [10/13 @ 19:27]  (1/2)

  • Hobbit qoutes???  <ElfEarz>  [10/13 @ 15:01]  (10/19)

  • Invisible clothes?  <irpacynot>  [10/13 @ 12:12]  (2/18)

  • Númenóreans  <irpacynot>  [10/13 @ 11:00]  (3/12)

  • Názgul  <Fingofin>  [10/13 @ 10:03]  (3/10)

  • Narya (spoiler)  <Goldilocks Took>  [10/12 @ 20:39]  (1/3)

  • From the Lothlorien Laboratory of Evolutionary Research.  <Reverend>  [10/12 @ 18:27]  (8/15)

  • This has been bugging me for some time.  <Stapper>  [10/12 @ 10:38]  (3/8)

  • Elladan and Elrohir  <LadyoftheElves9>  [10/12 @ 7:01]  (2/5)

  • The Arkenstone.  <NZ Strider>  [10/12 @ 0:08]  (2/2)

  • The Ruin: Esp. for Pukel-man!  <NZ Strider>  [10/11 @ 23:59]  (3/4)

  • Something truely tragic should have happened in LOTR  <Dedmon>  [10/11 @ 10:08]  (20/37)

  • How old is Arwen?  <Sheik Yerbouti>  [10/11 @ 9:43]  (2/2)

  • The Old Forest- Last Theory: Dreams  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/11 @ 8:10]  (4/8)

  • Beowulf paper  <Olorin of the West>  [10/11 @ 7:56]  (3/5)

  • Why did Tolkien write LOTR anyway?  <cabbage'n'taters>  [10/11 @ 7:05]  (3/9)

  • The Old Forest, #12- More Big Picture Theories  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/11 @ 6:12]  (2/2)

  • Why did Tolkien Choose the Elves  <Villordsutch>  [10/11 @ 1:51]  (2/10)

  • Justh finished my first reading, some questions  <Dedmon>  [10/10 @ 22:28]  (7/10)

  • I was browsing...  <Reverend>  [10/10 @ 19:48]  (4/26)

  • Sentinels . . .  <Pukel-man>  [10/10 @ 18:48]  (3/9)

  • Question in TTT book 3  The palantir  <tenrings>  [10/10 @ 17:06]  (2/5)

  • Istari as Professors  <Elwen>  [10/10 @ 16:38]  (10/17)

  • Is Nature the heroine of LotR?  <Curious>  [10/10 @ 12:56]  (4/8)

  • While there are so many people in the Reading Room- The Old Forest, #11- Big Picture Theories #1  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/10 @ 12:27]  (7/11)

  • Deleted threads  <Inferno>  [10/10 @ 11:55]  (7/17)

  • Should anyone like to take a look ...  <Aerlinn>  [10/10 @ 11:25]  (2/3)

  • The Old Forest, #10- Tom Bombadil  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/10 @ 8:27]  (7/14)

  • The Old Forest, #9- Tom and the Forest  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/10 @ 5:18]  (9/20)

  • Without giving away too much...  <irpacynot>  [10/9 @ 20:39]  (2/3)

  • Letters  <beren_boy>  [10/9 @ 17:47]  (5/12)

  • Frodo trying to save the Shire  <hot water nobility>  [10/9 @ 14:41]  (1/4)

  • HELP!  <Moiraine>  [10/9 @ 14:21]  (1/1)

  • The Old Forest, #8 1/2- An Observation  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/9 @ 14:20]  (4/13)

  • Two maps  <entish freedom fighter>  [10/9 @ 12:01]  (2/5)

  • Just Finished Reading  <Fundin>  [10/9 @ 11:45]  (17/19)

  • Whoops!!! *blushes* The Old Forest, #7- Help!  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/9 @ 11:18]  (4/5)

  • The Old Forest, #8- Forest affects  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/9 @ 9:36]  (4/6)

  • The Old Forest, #6- The Willow  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/9 @ 6:17]  (3/22)

  • Can someone help?  <paul101>  [10/9 @ 5:26]  (1/4)

  • The Elessar  <Moiraine>  [10/8 @ 22:48]  (5/12)

  • ent/old forest  <entish freedom fighter>  [10/8 @ 21:19]  (2/3)

  • The Road Goes Ever On...  <Gothmog, Lord of Balrogs>  [10/8 @ 16:22]  (1/9)

  • A challenge...  <PrincessArwen241>  [10/8 @ 15:32]  (7/9)

  • How do you pronounce Eowyn and Eomer?  <PrincessArwen241>  [10/8 @ 15:28]  (4/29)

  • The Old Forest, #5- Noises  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/8 @ 10:32]  (5/8)

  • Another way that Tolkien influenced CS Lewis??  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/8 @ 10:31]  (4/5)

  • The Old Forest, #4- Inner Forest  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/8 @ 5:14]  (7/9)

  • hobit feet  <entish freedom fighter>  [10/7 @ 17:39]  (5/34)

  • The Old Forest, #3- There's Something About Merry  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/7 @ 16:12]  (9/14)

  • The Old Forest, #2- History  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/7 @ 9:27]  (11/26)

  • Reposting from Main (Aragorn and Arwen's familial relationship)  <Inferno>  [10/7 @ 6:54]  (5/8)

  • Cirdan's Beard  <Gothmog, Lord of Balrogs>  [10/7 @ 5:56]  (6/19)

  • About the Chapter Discussions  <cubbyphan>  [10/6 @ 19:18]  (3/6)

  • The Old Forest, #1- Forest Personality  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/6 @ 19:09]  (10/22)

  • a small question  <Arador>  [10/6 @ 16:17]  (4/14)

  • mordor roads and the mogai plase reply with good answers  <tenrings>  [10/6 @ 13:00]  (3/7)

  • Comments about “A Conspiracy Unmasked.”  <Curious>  [10/5 @ 23:30]  (5/14)

  • Hey its ElfLordNick-I changed my name on here...  <ThorondorEagleofManwë>  [10/5 @ 14:57]  (3/4)

  • Some general thoughts on the transition from Shire to Old Forest  <NZ Strider>  [10/5 @ 14:41]  (5/6)

  • Quick question: Why give th Red Ring to "Gandy" when he wasn't an elf?  (No Text)  <SauronLover>  [10/5 @ 11:32]  (4/8)

  • The Ruin  <Pukel-man>  [10/5 @ 9:52]  (2/6)

  • Least favorite words  <Tar_Minastir>  [10/5 @ 9:37]  (9/25)

  • more on hobbit baths  <cabbage'n'taters>  [10/5 @ 7:15]  (3/5)

  • Movie cover books  <Jimmy Page>  [10/5 @ 6:44]  (3/7)

  • The origin of Tom Bombadil answered :-)  <Nemain>  [10/4 @ 19:50]  (5/8)

  • Orc sex?  <irpacynot>  [10/4 @ 16:17]  (6/20)

  • gandalf and aragorn in moria  <Fingofin>  [10/4 @ 15:05]  (7/17)

  • Sauron  <Fingofin>  [10/4 @ 14:53]  (1/1)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- Summary  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/4 @ 14:14]  (11/11)

  • ents  <Fingofin>  [10/4 @ 13:59]  (2/3)

  • Favorite words  <sundering_c>  [10/4 @ 12:32]  (16/27)

  • Why does Arwen have to choose mortality?  <iowaboy>  [10/4 @ 12:02]  (5/15)

  • Was HE there?  <Mandu>  [10/4 @ 9:44]  (7/10)

  • Lesser Rings - your opinions.  <Temujin>  [10/4 @ 7:59]  (5/13)

  • *is very confused*  <BJ>  [10/4 @ 7:31]  (2/3)

  • Smeagol and why  (Story Spoiler - LOTR-Fullstop)  <Villordsutch>  [10/4 @ 3:51]  (5/6)

  • Hungry Trees and Hobbits  (Story Spoiler - FOTR)  <Villordsutch>  [10/4 @ 3:03]  (4/9)

  • Bombadil and Goldberry . . .  <Pukel-man>  [10/3 @ 20:01]  (8/30)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- Into the Old Forest  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/3 @ 19:15]  (6/9)

  • question on saruman and saurons alliance  <tenrings>  [10/3 @ 18:45]  (1/2)

  • Question on Elvish Powers  <Fingon the brave>  [10/3 @ 17:34]  (2/4)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- Frodo  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/3 @ 14:45]  (7/9)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- The Story So Far  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/3 @ 14:39]  (2/5)

  • why doesn't Feanor return?  <Mister Frodo>  [10/3 @ 13:07]  (3/11)

  • simple question  <buttonboy3>  [10/3 @ 12:59]  (3/6)

  • pronunciation of names  <Astaldo>  [10/3 @ 10:35]  (2/4)

  • Q. Why was there no peace/healing for Miriel...  <Nemain>  [10/3 @ 8:03]  (2/9)

  • Orcs and lifespan  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [10/3 @ 1:11]  (2/25)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- The Conspirators  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/2 @ 19:56]  (5/12)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- Bath time!  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/2 @ 19:39]  (11/17)

  • We need to track Frodo's Dreams....  <Reverend>  [10/2 @ 19:18]  (7/22)

  • Chapter 5: A Conspiracy Unmasked -- Crossings  <Idril Celebrindal>  [10/2 @ 19:14]  (4/8)

  • A Conspiracy Unmasked-- a general sort of question  <Inferno>  [10/2 @ 18:29]  (4/5)

  • Failing the appearance of either  <Inferno>  [10/2 @ 18:27]  (1/1)

  • Witch-king question.  <cabbage'n'taters>  [10/2 @ 11:36]  (2/3)

  • Celeborn?  <Mela>  [10/2 @ 11:30]  (2/11)

  • Maybe this is a dumb question but...  <Murmuran>  [10/2 @ 8:10]  (7/16)

  • Revisiting the repeated themes disucssion (hopefully coherently)  <Inferno>  [10/2 @ 8:05]  (6/19)

  • The Fall of Gondolin question  <Lindir>  [10/2 @ 7:14]  (3/4)

  • My questions re "A Conspiracy Unmasked," Part 2: Money.  <Curious>  [10/2 @ 7:00]  (7/22)

  • My questions about "A Conspiracy Unmasked," Part 1: Did Merry Lie?  <Curious>  [10/2 @ 6:55]  (7/17)

  • Late ingredient to the "Frodo Using the One Ring" stew.  <Hama of Rohan>  [10/1 @ 20:14]  (3/6)

  • To Lady Aredhel.  <Curious>  [10/1 @ 19:19]  (3/3)

  • please someone answer this:  <Bboy486>  [10/1 @ 18:12]  (3/3)

  • Narn i hin Hurin Questions  <Diamond_of_Long_Cleave>  [10/1 @ 17:09]  (4/18)

  • Aman?  <irpacynot>  [10/1 @ 16:58]  (1/2)

  • Note on the Baggins estate.  <Reverend>  [10/1 @ 16:41]  (3/4)

  • Arwen's Story  <Luthien's Mama>  [10/1 @ 15:53]  (2/16)

  • trivia  <buttonboy3>  [10/1 @ 15:53]  (1/3)

  • I never....  <cabbage'n'taters>  [10/1 @ 15:37]  (2/3)

  • Can someone check my math?  <Curious>  [10/1 @ 14:15]  (11/42)

  • Bag End???  <cabbage'n'taters>  [10/1 @ 13:26]  (1/5)

  • Surnames in Middle Earth  <Thevina Finduilas>  [10/1 @ 9:17]  (4/10)

  • FotR side discussion: comparing Books I and II.  <Curious>  [10/1 @ 7:56]  (9/70)

  • Gandalf and the ring..  <Amatire>  [10/1 @ 3:59]  (1/12)

  •