2002
2003
2004

  • Gandalf and Galadriel  <Lorien-lover>  [11/15 @ 20:11]  (2/7)

  • A Knife in the Dark #11: The Attack  <Altaira>  [11/15 @ 18:41]  (6/23)

  • A Knife in The Dark #10: The Black Riders  <Altaira>  [11/15 @ 18:25]  (8/22)

  • Coincidence??  <Fingofin>  [11/15 @ 17:35]  (3/3)

  • caradhras  <Fingofin>  [11/15 @ 17:32]  (2/3)

  • shelob  <Fingofin>  [11/15 @ 17:22]  (1/3)

  • Sauron and the Ring  <Fingofin>  [11/15 @ 16:40]  (1/1)

  • What is the Silmarillion?  (Story Spoiler)  <Silmaril #3>  [11/15 @ 16:12]  (1/2)

  • Who's the stronger character?  <DaughterofRohan>  [11/15 @ 15:16]  (1/3)

  • Melkor's power???  <Lorien-lover>  [11/15 @ 14:08]  (1/3)

  • A hasty question about Ents.  <Mirime>  [11/15 @ 11:59]  (3/6)

  • on formlady of the ring earlier  <bilbojohnstone>  [11/15 @ 11:25]  (1/1)

  • Gandalf and Bilbo became friends how?  <eddy>  [11/15 @ 9:23]  (2/3)

  • NZ Strider--  <Inferno>  [11/15 @ 8:56]  (1/6)

  • OT: the mooted film 'Troy' . . .  <Pukel-man>  [11/15 @ 5:16]  (4/20)

  • nine finger theory  <ladyofthe_rings>  [11/14 @ 20:32]  (3/8)

  • Does anyone know  <Balin son of Fouldin>  [11/14 @ 19:53]  (1/2)

  • A Knife in the Dark #9 – The Tale of Tinuviel  <Altaira>  [11/14 @ 19:47]  (6/6)

  • A Knife in the Dark #8 – The view from Weathertop  <Altaira>  [11/14 @ 19:37]  (5/11)

  • A Knife in the Dark #7 – Neekerbreekers and a Light Show  <Altaira>  [11/14 @ 19:33]  (9/13)

  • Brilliant Shippey comment.  <Curious>  [11/14 @ 10:56]  (1/1)

  • I wonder what Old Man Willow would think.  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Curious>  [11/14 @ 7:42]  (10/25)

  • My new bag of questions  <PhantomS>  [11/14 @ 6:45]  (3/5)

  • The most powerful race in middle-earth  <Eiji_Hitokiri>  [11/14 @ 1:20]  (3/3)

  • Does Gothmog in ROTK=Gothmog in the Silmarillion?  <A_Tossed_Dwarf>  [11/13 @ 22:15]  (1/2)

  • A Knife in the Dark:  #6 – The Lay of The Land  <Altaira>  [11/13 @ 20:44]  (8/13)

  • I'm Doing a Literary Analysis of Tolkien's Works - Suggestions/Help Needed!  <A_Tossed_Dwarf>  [11/13 @ 20:00]  (3/23)

  • A Knife in the Dark:  #5 – Concerning Strider:  2  <Altaira>  [11/13 @ 18:35]  (5/15)

  • A Knife in the Dark:  #4 – Concerning Strider:  1  <Altaira>  [11/13 @ 18:27]  (7/7)

  • in the tradition of Curious  <Demosthenes>  [11/13 @ 18:06]  (4/10)

  • Elven Lords at Imladris  <Muster of Rohan 29>  [11/13 @ 13:30]  (1/9)

  • Striking Sauron and the Nazgul?  <Lancelot>  [11/13 @ 12:53]  (3/11)

  • tickets  <Tulin>  [11/13 @ 11:57]  (1/1)

  • YAEQ (Yet Another Elf Question)  <Hama of Rohan>  [11/13 @ 7:57]  (5/36)

  • The Hobbit  <Song of Eru>  [11/12 @ 23:09]  (1/6)

  • All that is gold does not glitter...  <Lord-Smeagol>  [11/12 @ 19:46]  (1/1)

  • Does anyone remember  <Erinti>  [11/12 @ 18:10]  (4/5)

  • A Knife in the Dark:  #3 – Frodo’s Third Dream  <Altaira>  [11/12 @ 14:39]  (8/15)

  • Inspired by a thread on Movie: Was Faramir tempted by the ring?  <Lottelita>  [11/12 @ 14:12]  (3/8)

  • Rangers  <kingunderthemountain>  [11/12 @ 12:01]  (2/2)

  • This may not be on the right board.  <Merryk>  [11/12 @ 11:16]  (4/5)

  • Half-Elven characters  <Eggie>  [11/12 @ 9:47]  (1/2)

  • Was Legolas the last...  <Eggie>  [11/12 @ 9:46]  (1/1)

  • Further thoughts on Faërie in LotR.  <Curious>  [11/12 @ 6:34]  (7/55)

  • Regarding whether Tolkien sympathized with the Old Forest.  <Curious>  [11/12 @ 3:37]  (1/8)

  • Aragorn's Ring  <jonathanh84>  [11/11 @ 23:53]  (1/2)

  • Who's the best army as far as skill.  <Arod the Swift>  [11/11 @ 21:09]  (6/13)

  • A Knife in the Dark:  #2 – Nazgul Navigation  <Altaira>  [11/11 @ 19:08]  (6/8)

  • A Knife in the Dark:  #1 - FEAR!  FIRE!  FOES!  <Altaira>  [11/11 @ 17:31]  (10/16)

  • I am sure this was already discussed but...  <Murmuran>  [11/11 @ 12:50]  (1/2)

  • a tad confused  <Murmuran>  [11/11 @ 12:48]  (1/3)

  • Quick FYI - Part 8 of the Annotated Transcript is up!  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Aerlinn>  [11/11 @ 10:06]  (2/2)

  • Hobbits'  room attackers ruffians not wraiths?  <cabbage'n'taters>  [11/11 @ 5:11]  (4/22)

  • Question on Knights  <PhantomS>  [11/10 @ 18:37]  (2/14)

  • Anything written about...  <BJ>  [11/10 @ 17:27]  (2/4)

  • “On the Origin of Elves” (long post)  <Tauriel>  [11/10 @ 15:43]  (10/31)

  • What happened to the  <BrambleroseBrandybuck>  [11/10 @ 14:20]  (2/2)

  • Wizards  <HellFire>  [11/10 @ 12:10]  (1/1)

  • and another ring question,  <SauronLover>  [11/10 @ 11:22]  (4/8)

  • A ring question,  <SauronLover>  [11/10 @ 11:18]  (2/8)

  • sorry to ask this, i know it's been asked and answered 10^6x, but...  <summertime>  [11/10 @ 10:27]  (3/7)

  • Do you think Goldberry was immune to the Ring?  <Curious>  [11/9 @ 21:52]  (4/12)

  • OT: Screwtape Letters  <Julie of the pointed ears>  [11/9 @ 18:00]  (2/2)

  • Elrond  <ThorondorEagleofManwë>  [11/9 @ 16:30]  (2/29)

  • Why couldn't they have made a movie book cover for THE HOBBIT  to go along with the rest?  <thiefbaggins>  [11/9 @ 8:11]  (4/5)

  • A request for help from those who have read LotR and The Sil.  <Curious>  [11/9 @ 7:11]  (12/26)

  • About ME situation between the end of the siege of Angbad, and the War of Wrath: (spoilers)  <Fingon the brave>  [11/8 @ 17:24]  (1/3)

  • FAO NZ Strider  <LordM>  [11/8 @ 17:06]  (1/9)

  • Was Earendil an elf or a human?  (No Text)  <Dryhten>  [11/8 @ 14:21]  (5/16)

  • Strider #15: Conclusion  <Tauriel>  [11/8 @ 13:22]  (16/18)

  • just started reading RETURN OF THE KING  <thiefbaggins>  [11/8 @ 11:01]  (5/5)

  • Elves?  <Lasselanta of Mirkwood>  [11/8 @ 7:17]  (2/8)

  • ”Strider” #14: Anything overlooked  <Tauriel>  [11/8 @ 5:23]  (2/27)

  • To Inferno and Altaira  <Lady Aredhel>  [11/8 @ 4:36]  (1/2)

  • ”Strider” #13: ”Movie vs. Book”  <Tauriel>  [11/8 @ 4:00]  (13/38)

  • Carl Jung site  <cabbage'n'taters>  [11/7 @ 22:45]  (4/9)

  • Quick FYI - Part 7 of the Annotated Transcript is up!  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Aerlinn>  [11/7 @ 20:15]  (0/0)

  • Something troubling in ME...rxns to the Sil  <summertime>  [11/7 @ 17:37]  (3/19)

  • Tolkien's view of the hero in LOTR  <Oakenshield>  [11/7 @ 15:17]  (9/23)

  • Is the 'secret fire'....?  and What or where is 'the void'?  <Lancelot>  [11/7 @ 12:50]  (2/7)

  • ”Strider” #12: ”The End” (no, not of the discussion ;-))  <Tauriel>  [11/7 @ 12:03]  (4/4)

  • A question about THE HOBBIT  <thiefbaggins>  [11/7 @ 11:29]  (2/10)

  • Regarding Letter 131 (with a link).  <Curious>  [11/7 @ 9:39]  (2/2)

  • ”Strider” #11: ”I’m a Poor Lonesome Ranger”  <Tauriel>  [11/7 @ 5:57]  (6/30)

  • Laws and Customs and all dat  <PhantomS>  [11/7 @ 4:54]  (2/9)

  • ”Strider” #10: “Chasing Black Riders”  <Tauriel>  [11/7 @ 3:13]  (4/10)

  • The Icelandic Sagas as an influence on Tolkien . . .  <Pukel-man>  [11/7 @ 2:40]  (4/17)

  • A more scholarly Jungian analysis.  <Curious>  [11/6 @ 23:13]  (8/21)

  • What is Sauron???  <the_hobbit_girl>  [11/6 @ 20:28]  (4/4)

  • Bilbo's name  <notlost>  [11/6 @ 20:25]  (3/7)

  • Gothmog alive in ROTK?  <O'Possum>  [11/6 @ 17:41]  (1/2)

  • This question is completely unrelated  <shadow baggins>  [11/6 @ 17:38]  (3/8)

  • A few good questions  <entish freedom fighter>  [11/6 @ 15:45]  (2/8)

  • Reading Order?  <ecantrell>  [11/6 @ 14:28]  (3/7)

  • Here's a brief but interesting essay  <Curious>  [11/6 @ 14:27]  (5/5)

  • Thoughts about Balrogs  <Inferno>  [11/6 @ 11:26]  (5/11)

  • ”Strider” #9: ”More to a Wizard Than Meets the Eye”  <Tauriel>  [11/6 @ 11:07]  (5/5)

  • Shelob question  <Aragorn_Elessar>  [11/6 @ 10:48]  (1/2)

  • So what about the Sagas . . . ?  <Pukel-man>  [11/6 @ 10:21]  (2/6)

  • LotR, a tale with (at least) two endings.  <Curious>  [11/6 @ 8:51]  (3/6)

  • Do we ever learn why Melkor rebelled?  <Dryhten>  [11/6 @ 7:00]  (1/2)

  • ”Strider” #8: “Fair is Foul and Foul is Fair – Or How Was That Again?”  <Tauriel>  [11/6 @ 6:20]  (4/22)

  • ”Strider” #7: “Different Approaches to the Unknown”  <Tauriel>  [11/6 @ 1:36]  (5/8)

  • When does the fellowship actually "end"?  <the_hobbit_girl>  [11/5 @ 19:55]  (3/9)

  • Fog on the Barrow Downs question...  <Taryávëwen >  [11/5 @ 14:41]  (3/3)

  • Line from the movie  <Count Dooku>  [11/5 @ 14:37]  (1/3)

  • Denethor's suicide and Aragorn's death  <Tar_Minastir>  [11/5 @ 14:30]  (6/14)

  • Concerning The Istar  <Bboy486>  [11/5 @ 13:41]  (2/6)

  • Did Frodo have to sail with Bilbo?  <Curious>  [11/5 @ 11:17]  (7/18)

  • ”Strider” #6: ”What if…?”  <Tauriel>  [11/5 @ 11:00]  (3/5)

  • Were the hobbits nudists?  <cabbage'n'taters>  [11/5 @ 10:44]  (3/7)

  • Dwarf Females  <Wights R Us>  [11/5 @ 7:25]  (6/13)

  • ”Strider” #5: “Gandalf’s Hasty Letter”  <Tauriel>  [11/5 @ 6:00]  (7/19)

  • ”Strider” #4: Barliman Butterbur  <Tauriel>  [11/5 @ 1:10]  (7/32)

  • Luthien: other suitors?  <aragonvaar>  [11/4 @ 19:22]  (3/4)

  • Question: Why is death the "gift of men?"  <Dryhten>  [11/4 @ 18:35]  (5/17)

  • Question  <Caitie-the-Slightly-Ecru>  [11/4 @ 17:23]  (2/3)

  • Glorfindel from Sil = Glorfindel from LOTR?  <summertime>  [11/4 @ 16:33]  (2/16)

  • How come...  <BJ>  [11/4 @ 15:38]  (1/3)

  • Re-post from Main:  Hanover Winter Song  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [11/4 @ 14:41]  (2/7)

  • Tom Bombadil  <ElfLordElronor>  [11/4 @ 14:29]  (8/11)

  • What next?  <zoink>  [11/4 @ 14:06]  (2/2)

  • Aragorn and Gandalf. Just how did they meet?  <Lady_Dunedain>  [11/4 @ 14:06]  (1/5)

  • Frodo's Dream  <Taryávëwen >  [11/4 @ 13:20]  (6/6)

  • ”Strider” #3: ”Strider, the Mysterious Stranger”  <Tauriel>  [11/4 @ 13:18]  (6/18)

  • Galadriel and Celeborn question  <Hobbit-Of-No-Intelligence>  [11/4 @ 12:44]  (1/3)

  • Lesser Rings...  <Myrddin Wylt>  [11/4 @ 12:22]  (1/4)

  • FYI: Part 6 of the Annotated Transcript is up!  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Aerlinn>  [11/4 @ 11:57]  (1/1)

  • Aragorn's Age  <kungfudude>  [11/4 @ 11:44]  (2/6)

  • Question about Sam and The Ring  <mikeb210>  [11/4 @ 10:17]  (5/17)

  • ”Strider” #2: ”Getting To Know Your Enemies”:  <Tauriel>  [11/4 @ 9:16]  (7/9)

  • Reencarnation of Gandalf  <Balin son of Fouldin>  [11/4 @ 8:18]  (1/1)

  • we all know  <bilbojohnstone>  [11/4 @ 4:29]  (4/6)

  • "Strider" #1: "Things Not To Do When You Want To Be Trusted"  <Tauriel>  [11/4 @ 4:00]  (5/44)

  • how long do normal Peredhil live?  <Arador>  [11/3 @ 17:15]  (1/9)

  • Galadriel and Celeborn  <shadow baggins>  [11/3 @ 15:27]  (1/2)

  • Flame of Arnor, flame of Udun-what  <Balin son of Fouldin>  [11/3 @ 13:48]  (5/8)

  • Question on aragorn  <PervyElfFancier>  [11/3 @ 13:30]  (3/13)

  • Translation  <Forgil>  [11/3 @ 12:46]  (1/1)

  • Some quick notes on proper names in Breeland and environs  <NZ Strider>  [11/3 @ 10:50]  (2/4)

  • A few Q regarding Tolkien's Letters and Unfinished Tales  <Called_Curunir>  [11/3 @ 10:19]  (4/7)

  • path of the dead  <tenrings>  [11/3 @ 10:01]  (3/4)

  • question Sam and Frodo  <Goldilocks Took>  [11/3 @ 8:07]  (3/14)

  • osgiliath  <tenrings>  [11/3 @ 7:43]  (2/3)

  • next best Tolkien book after LOTR  <fixer>  [11/3 @ 3:20]  (5/7)

  • Mirkwood  <Bboy486>  [11/2 @ 17:44]  (1/11)

  • SAuron question  <Bboy486>  [11/2 @ 17:25]  (1/3)

  • The feminine form of evil  <SauronLover>  [11/2 @ 9:46]  (6/23)

  • At The Sign of the Prancing Pony - Conclusion  <Ufthak>  [11/2 @ 8:40]  (14/18)

  • Prince Imrahil's elven blood - a source!  <Lothirienne>  [11/2 @ 7:51]  (2/7)

  • Just how old is The Prancing Pony?  <Curious>  [11/1 @ 20:08]  (1/11)

  • Why was there so much less "coming and going" between the Shire and Bree than in the past?  (No Text)  <Curious>  [11/1 @ 20:07]  (1/2)

  • Was Tolkien a true Luddite?  <Curious>  [11/1 @ 15:57]  (2/9)

  • palantir-nazgúl  <Fingofin>  [11/1 @ 14:55]  (1/3)

  • Calendar leaders for November:  <Inferno>  [11/1 @ 13:40]  (1/1)

  • Why was the scouring of the Shire so easy?  <Curious>  [11/1 @ 9:30]  (9/40)

  • musings  <PhantomS>  [11/1 @ 6:57]  (3/5)

  • Maggot and Bombadil  <Aussie>  [11/1 @ 4:57]  (1/1)

  • moss gatherer  <bilbojohnstone>  [11/1 @ 4:32]  (1/1)

  • At The Sign of The Prancing Pony - #7 A Beginner’s Guide to how to Blow Your Cover  <Ufthak>  [11/1 @ 2:58]  (8/13)

  •