2002
2003
2004

  • question about Gandalf - TTT spoiler  <Balrog Boy>  [7/31 @ 19:45]  (3/16)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen #9 - Summary  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/31 @ 18:49]  (1/5)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen #8  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/31 @ 18:47]  (2/2)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen #7  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/31 @ 18:22]  (3/4)

  • where can i find the original Hobbit?  <amanda marie>  [7/31 @ 17:52]  (2/7)

  • I am sick of Balrogs -- let's talk Dragons! (III)  <NZ Strider>  [7/31 @ 16:37]  (2/9)

  • Please answer  <Polly>  [7/31 @ 16:26]  (3/7)

  • What is Frodo's Gift?  <WillakaLliw>  [7/31 @ 16:07]  (2/4)

  • if any of you are walking-talking-dictionaries...  <amanda marie>  [7/31 @ 15:40]  (2/4)

  • Sometime in the future . . .  <Annael>  [7/31 @ 13:13]  (4/4)

  • question regarding Chapter V, FOTR, Book I  <legolasrules>  [7/31 @ 11:17]  (2/6)

  • I just got the Silmarillion! Help!  <canadanthony>  [7/31 @ 10:56]  (6/9)

  • a question  <SauronLover>  [7/31 @ 10:41]  (1/13)

  • Should Tolkien's translators translate poetry literally, or try to make it scan?  <Karen>  [7/31 @ 9:16]  (7/14)

  • Another reason there are no dragons in LOTR  <cabbage'n'taters>  [7/31 @ 8:34]  (3/14)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen #5  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/30 @ 19:48]  (3/5)

  • I am sick of Balrogs -- let's talk Dragons! (II)  <NZ Strider>  [7/30 @ 19:38]  (4/30)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen, #6  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/30 @ 18:56]  (4/11)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen #4  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/30 @ 18:39]  (2/5)

  • How do you do those little thingies that appear  <Lady Greenarcher>  [7/30 @ 17:37]  (2/2)

  • question u may no the answer to  ...please read  <Balrog Boy>  [7/30 @ 14:19]  (1/2)

  • I am sick of Balrogs -- let's talk Dragons (I)  <NZ Strider>  [7/30 @ 14:06]  (4/10)

  • The colour of a wizard's beard  <G>  [7/30 @ 13:11]  (3/8)

  • What happened to the other dragons?  <Curious>  [7/30 @ 10:47]  (4/7)

  • Morgoth v. Sauron  <Valar Wannabe>  [7/30 @ 7:46]  (5/7)

  • So whats everyones favourite chapter in the Silmarillion?  <Sirithdarion>  [7/30 @ 2:28]  (9/16)

  • Question.  <moi>  [7/29 @ 22:23]  (4/15)

  • crosspost form M: unanswerable questions  <Arador>  [7/29 @ 21:59]  (3/3)

  • I have a question about Elves as children  <Entmaiden>  [7/29 @ 21:01]  (1/5)

  • UT: The Battles of the Fords of Isen #3  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/29 @ 19:07]  (4/8)

  • UT:  The Battles of the Fords of Isen, #2  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/29 @ 18:52]  (4/12)

  • UT:  The Battles of the Fords of Isen, #1  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/29 @ 18:32]  (7/16)

  • Elrond in Dale?  <Altaira>  [7/29 @ 18:20]  (5/21)

  • Paging Lady Aredhel...  <Altaira>  [7/29 @ 17:55]  (1/2)

  • Grishnákh  <Miguel>  [7/29 @ 7:47]  (1/2)

  • Votes are tallied.  <Inferno>  [7/29 @ 6:50]  (3/4)

  • Why were the Astari sent then?  <Temujin>  [7/29 @ 5:44]  (1/8)

  • The Battles of the Fords of Isen  <Lady Aredhel>  [7/29 @ 4:44]  (0/0)

  • question about the Sil...  <Frodosgurl>  [7/28 @ 19:22]  (5/6)

  • UT -- “The Hunt for the Ring” -- Summary  <Curious>  [7/28 @ 5:01]  (12/13)

  • how....  <ElfLordNick>  [7/28 @ 3:38]  (1/1)

  • A reminder  <Eledhwen>  [7/28 @ 1:57]  (4/8)

  • Does anyone know any insults in Elvish?  <BrambleroseBbuck>  [7/27 @ 20:33]  (7/10)

  • Is anyone else aware...  <BrambleroseBbuck>  [7/27 @ 20:19]  (3/3)

  • What metal are the rings of power made of?  <BrambleroseBbuck>  [7/27 @ 19:49]  (2/6)

  • This might be a dumb question  <tara120FO>  [7/27 @ 10:19]  (3/3)

  • Can I add my vote?  <Eledhwen>  [7/27 @ 8:39]  (0/0)

  • hobbit vs. LOTR  <UndomielEvenstar>  [7/27 @ 8:16]  (8/10)

  • Just curious, but there isn't any mention of "the cats of Queen Beruthiel" other than in The Fellowship of the Ring, is there?  (No Text)  <Rider Of The Rohirrim>  [7/27 @ 7:54]  (2/8)

  • Q. Which union of the Valar do you find unusual. To me it is Mandos and Vaire....  <Nemain>  [7/26 @ 21:48]  (2/9)

  • Why didn't the Orcs ride horses? Or did they?  (No Text)  <cabbage'n'taters>  [7/26 @ 20:53]  (1/3)

  • Q. Is there any mention of how or why the Hobbit race came to be.  <Nemain>  [7/26 @ 20:32]  (2/9)

  • Q. What do you think would be the most interesting enigma Tolkien created in ME.  <Nemain>  [7/26 @ 17:09]  (8/33)

  • 2 things...your opinion may depend on it.  <ElfLordNick>  [7/26 @ 16:26]  (5/24)

  • The Paths of the Dead  <Taryávëwen >  [7/26 @ 12:45]  (2/11)

  • Which Two Towers?  <regulat0r>  [7/26 @ 12:43]  (4/7)

  • My take on why the White Council and Gandalf deferred to Saruman (a long post, even by my standards).  <Curious>  [7/26 @ 11:30]  (8/19)

  • Happy System Administrators Day!  <Curious>  [7/26 @ 9:52]  (6/7)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The Black Captain's camp and visit to the Barrow-downs.  <Curious>  [7/26 @ 8:38]  (2/9)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The Dunlending in Bree.  <Curious>  [7/26 @ 8:33]  (4/5)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The importance of Bree and ignorance of the Shire.  <Curious>  [7/26 @ 8:31]  (2/5)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The Barrow-wight.  <Curious>  [7/26 @ 8:30]  (3/3)

  • OT: Curious - about alt.fan.tolkien link  <Hama of Rohan>  [7/26 @ 7:19]  (1/3)

  • Should there be an abridged version of the book?  <Meathrel>  [7/26 @ 2:58]  (14/34)

  • This is embarrassing  <Gil-galad Of Líndon>  [7/26 @ 2:00]  (4/7)

  • This may be silly: A thought about Tom  <Caleniel>  [7/26 @ 0:56]  (4/9)

  • I started the Sil today and I was wondering...  <Taryávëwen >  [7/25 @ 20:21]  (3/8)

  • Q. Does anyone know what Dunharrow actually was...a city, burial place or temple of some kind.  <Nemain>  [7/25 @ 19:41]  (2/10)

  • Q. Does anyone know which Edain houses the Easterlings and the people of Harad derive from  <Nemain>  [7/25 @ 19:06]  (1/2)

  • Can someone please explain the Barrow-wight to me better?  <esiwmas>  [7/25 @ 18:46]  (3/6)

  • Another Arthur influence?  <Arador>  [7/25 @ 18:36]  (0/0)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Open discussion.  <Curious>  [7/25 @ 14:31]  (0/0)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Saruman, the insolent deceiver.  <Curious>  [7/25 @ 14:30]  (5/9)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Saruman's near-repentance.  <Curious>  [7/25 @ 14:29]  (3/11)

  • My first post here! OK, here goes: Atalantë = Atlantis?  <Earendil The Mariner>  [7/25 @ 11:54]  (4/17)

  • Would Sauron and Bill Gates have gotten along?  <Temujin>  [7/25 @ 10:40]  (3/8)

  • How about a simultaneous Hobbit and FOTR?  <Patty>  [7/25 @ 7:48]  (1/4)

  • Reading Room Chapter Discussion: Official Vote Thread  <Inferno>  [7/25 @ 6:56]  (50/53)

  • My big story - References needed  (Mini-Spoiler - ROTK)  <Villordsutch>  [7/25 @ 5:16]  (2/9)

  • Curses  <cubbyphan>  [7/24 @ 17:40]  (2/7)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Gollum in Moria.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 17:33]  (4/16)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Aragorn's 900-mile Gollum-drive.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 17:32]  (4/14)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – "I'm melting!" – the Nazguls' fear of sun and water.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 17:31]  (3/7)

  • Dagor Dagorath  <sundering_c>  [7/24 @ 13:07]  (4/16)

  • Regarding the Official Nomination Thread below.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 8:56]  (3/4)

  • Help with an elven word  <TwiztidWiccan>  [7/24 @ 8:46]  (1/1)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The battle at Sarn Ford.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 6:46]  (5/21)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Saruman's inaction.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 6:33]  (4/8)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Gollum's escape from Orcs and Elves.  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 6:32]  (4/11)

  • Does anyone care to deconstruct LotR?  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Curious>  [7/24 @ 5:42]  (5/34)

  • Humbly seeking sage advice with my first post here: Dior's fate?  <Hama of Rohan>  [7/23 @ 22:34]  (3/14)

  • The Light of Elendil  <Meathrel>  [7/23 @ 21:06]  (2/4)

  • Q. Does Prof Tolkien provide a definition for the use of power or magic in Middle Earth.  (No Text)  <Nemain>  [7/23 @ 20:11]  (2/5)

  • The books  <Legolas's_Girl>  [7/23 @ 13:17]  (5/15)

  • palantirs  <Lhunithiliel>  [7/23 @ 12:35]  (3/5)

  • UT: Palantiri  <ithilwen>  [7/23 @ 12:15]  (2/6)

  • Reading Room Chapter Discussion: Official Nomination Thread  <Inferno>  [7/23 @ 11:37]  (13/43)

  • To PhantomS  <Gil-galad Of Líndon>  [7/23 @ 10:24]  (1/2)

  • For Curious- more Gollum musings  <Thevina Finduilas>  [7/23 @ 9:39]  (1/2)

  • The Ring and it's powers...  <Meathrel>  [7/23 @ 9:15]  (2/3)

  • The Love Story  <Meathrel>  [7/23 @ 9:06]  (5/9)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The secret life of the Nazgul.  <Curious>  [7/23 @ 7:53]  (7/29)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Did Aragorn withstand the Nazgul?  <Curious>  [7/23 @ 7:52]  (5/16)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The blank spot on Sauron's map.  <Curious>  [7/23 @ 7:50]  (6/13)

  • For Earendil the Mariner; a lost question  <Reverend>  [7/23 @ 6:35]  (4/10)

  • The New Shadow - 12 pages  <Villordsutch>  [7/23 @ 6:32]  (1/3)

  • Arwen's mortality  <novemberfrost>  [7/23 @ 5:40]  (2/2)

  • Did all other races just fade away?  <Blindleader>  [7/22 @ 22:22]  (2/2)

  • The Horn of Gondor???  <Cutter>  [7/22 @ 20:46]  (1/3)

  • Q. Do you think The Shadow Bride in the Adventures of Tom Bombadil could well refer to Eol and Aredhel?  <Nemain>  [7/22 @ 20:33]  (3/3)

  • Bombadil  <MadMelkor>  [7/22 @ 19:38]  (4/13)

  • Scouring of the Shire & Socialism/Communism  <hobbitfoot>  [7/22 @ 18:46]  (5/8)

  • Q. The island of Tol Morwen is all that remains of Beleriand. Was this due to the powers of the Valar or the seer and harpsinger Glirhuin.  <Nemain>  [7/22 @ 18:05]  (2/8)

  • Slightly OT: Comparing LotR to His Dark Materials  <Keriway>  [7/22 @ 13:45]  (5/12)

  • Rings and giving  <EldersisofMerry>  [7/22 @ 11:34]  (3/16)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Gollum's "escape" from Mordor.  <Curious>  [7/22 @ 10:25]  (4/13)

  • Ettenmoors  <Razanur Tuc>  [7/22 @ 9:28]  (1/1)

  • Poll: What is your favorite quote?  <Luthien__>  [7/22 @ 7:32]  (11/13)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – The indomitable Gollum.  <Curious>  [7/22 @ 7:15]  (6/19)

  • UT: "The Hunt for the Ring" – Is this canon?  <Curious>  [7/22 @ 7:09]  (5/19)

  • When Beren and Luthien came back from the dead, did Beren still have only one hand?  <Smokering>  [7/22 @ 3:48]  (1/2)

  • a question for scholars.....  <Dirk Diggler>  [7/22 @ 0:03]  (4/5)

  • Guys - a post on Main asking whether orcs are immortal or not:  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Ataahua>  [7/21 @ 21:09]  (0/0)

  • Aragorn's lucky  yet mysterious fate...  <Cutter>  [7/21 @ 20:49]  (9/17)

  • The ring's Seduction  <Cutter>  [7/21 @ 20:45]  (2/3)

  • Smokering!!!!!  <burma>  [7/21 @ 18:18]  (1/16)

  • I wonder...did Tolkien ever make....  <ElfLordNick>  [7/21 @ 16:26]  (2/2)

  • So, was Legolas really a blonde?  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [7/21 @ 10:08]  (7/11)

  • What else is there?  <farstriker>  [7/21 @ 10:04]  (3/10)

  • Dwarven Kingdoms  <Gil-galad Of Líndon>  [7/21 @ 4:52]  (4/17)

  • the chosen one  <Cutter>  [7/20 @ 22:22]  (4/10)

  • should we believe in UT or LOTR?  <Arador>  [7/20 @ 20:46]  (3/11)

  • UT: Quest of Erebor -- Wrap-up  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/20 @ 19:18]  (9/9)

  • Did the Orcs call themselves "Orcs"?  (No Text)  <cabbage'n'taters>  [7/20 @ 8:37]  (2/14)

  • Do we know that Cirdan left with Frodo et al.?  <Curious>  [7/20 @ 6:57]  (6/14)

  • Gilraen's last words  <novemberfrost>  [7/20 @ 3:58]  (2/8)

  • Q. I do wonder what you make of the last paragraph of the Silmarillion page 255.  <Nemain>  [7/19 @ 20:18]  (3/9)

  • Q. How many dwarven tribes are there in North Western Middle Earth?  <Nemain>  [7/19 @ 18:27]  (1/5)

  • Appendix question  <Taryávëwen >  [7/19 @ 10:39]  (1/2)

  • The 3 Great Rings  <Jus>  [7/19 @ 10:05]  (6/13)

  • Elf names  <Legolas's_Girl>  [7/19 @ 9:32]  (3/7)

  • Hobbit Ladies.....  <Taryávëwen >  [7/19 @ 8:58]  (1/9)

  • Mt. Doom Scene  (Story Spoiler - ROTK)  <ElfLordNick>  [7/19 @ 7:09]  (6/10)

  • Following Works 4th Age...and also  <Villordsutch>  [7/19 @ 5:32]  (2/8)

  • Who were J Tolkien really?  <Gil-galad Of Líndon>  [7/19 @ 5:25]  (3/5)

  • One image to treasure....  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [7/19 @ 4:55]  (9/14)

  • Can anyone explain why Tolkien used no "J" names?  <Curious>  [7/19 @ 4:35]  (2/4)

  • OT: Attn. Watson  <NZ Strider>  [7/18 @ 21:05]  (1/1)

  • Q. Which elven race did Sauron take form of to become "fair and wise" to the elves in the Second Age.  <Nemain>  [7/18 @ 20:23]  (3/9)

  • Elves  <Legolas's_Girl>  [7/18 @ 19:59]  (3/8)

  • Q. Is there any references to any events beyond Fourth Age 120  <Nemain>  [7/18 @ 18:52]  (1/4)

  • Elf Kids, Female Dwarfs and the Three Elven Rings! Oh MY!  (Story Spoiler - ROTK)  <ElfLordNick>  [7/18 @ 17:37]  (7/8)

  • Sadly, not LoTR related  <ThorinStonehelm>  [7/18 @ 16:16]  (7/7)

  • The Ring: what would its bearers powers actually be?  <Nightfall>  [7/18 @ 14:15]  (5/6)

  • A plea for a little more civility on this board  <NZ Strider>  [7/18 @ 13:29]  (8/37)

  • Really good book...  <Arwen_Undomiel>  [7/18 @ 11:14]  (1/1)

  • A question about dwarfe names  <Draupne>  [7/18 @ 9:38]  (2/6)

  • UT: The Quest of Erebor -- The Map of Thror  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/18 @ 8:33]  (4/9)

  • UT: The Quest of Erebor -- Burglar Baggins?  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/18 @ 8:30]  (4/10)

  • Question on Sauron and the Ring  <Mrs. Boromir>  [7/18 @ 8:30]  (3/4)

  • Help! Re next week's UT chapter  <Eledhwen>  [7/18 @ 7:46]  (1/2)

  • 2 questions please if anyone could help  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [7/18 @ 6:35]  (1/4)

  • Ages - How long  <Villordsutch>  [7/18 @ 3:47]  (1/3)

  • Probaly easier to throw the One into the Fires of Mount Doom than.....  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [7/18 @ 1:59]  (3/11)

  • What the heck ? - 'The Annotated Hobbit'  <Villordsutch>  [7/18 @ 0:53]  (2/4)

  • Q. Which bird does the Crebain resemble in our world...the Crow..Raven..  <Nemain>  [7/17 @ 18:24]  (1/19)

  • More on immortality and fading -- this time the Valar  <NZ Strider>  [7/17 @ 15:55]  (2/3)

  • The history of Gandolf (spoilers)  <slavefive>  [7/17 @ 9:29]  (2/8)

  • UT: Quest of Erebor -- Savage swords and dragon fire!  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/17 @ 7:04]  (3/5)

  • UT: The Quest of Erebor -- The role of the Ring  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/17 @ 6:52]  (3/4)

  • On the missing wisards  <Nightfall>  [7/17 @ 1:47]  (2/6)

  • Sauron the Necromancer  <NZ Strider>  [7/16 @ 22:55]  (1/4)

  • Did Frodo fail?  <Blindleader>  [7/16 @ 20:48]  (6/20)

  • Comparing the Arkenstone to known gems...  <Keriway>  [7/16 @ 18:21]  (5/11)

  • A little help with the Quest for Erebor  <joannaspring>  [7/16 @ 16:42]  (3/7)

  • Some material from The Treason of Isengard  <NZ Strider>  [7/16 @ 16:07]  (2/9)

  • UT: The Quest of Erebor -- Dwarf cities?  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/16 @ 7:24]  (1/16)

  • UT: THe Quest of Erebor -- Thorin's motivations  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/16 @ 7:19]  (4/7)

  • UT: Quest of Erebor -- Bilbo's motivations  <Idril Celebrindal>  [7/16 @ 7:09]  (3/5)

  •