2002
2003
2004

  • I have this chapter :-)  <Lady Aredhel>  [9/30 @ 21:05]  (1/1)

  • Answers/opinions needed on Frodo's use of the Ring: NZ_Strider: you commented on this once; others also welcome...  <mallorn-ws>  [9/30 @ 15:51]  (7/58)

  • I looked up a few things about the "Eye"; (slight rantings and a trailer spoiler)  <iowaboy>  [9/30 @ 15:39]  (3/17)

  • concerning the seven  <Bboy486>  [9/30 @ 13:47]  (1/3)

  • TTT and ROTK Questions (Gray Havens)  <Mandu>  [9/30 @ 11:40]  (2/8)

  • Before I just drop EldersisofMerry off the list...  <Inferno>  [9/30 @ 8:31]  (3/3)

  • So, Curious, where's part 30 already?  (No Text)  <Reverend>  [9/30 @ 7:47]  (1/7)

  • Chapter discussion begins tonight  <Idril Celebrindal>  [9/30 @ 7:34]  (0/0)

  • ME ancient Europe?  <irpacynot>  [9/29 @ 19:11]  (6/29)

  • The Seven  <Pukel-man>  [9/29 @ 18:25]  (4/11)

  • Note to Hobbit-Of-No-Intellegence  <ElfLordNick>  [9/29 @ 17:17]  (0/0)

  • do elves cry?  <Sģlmaričn>  [9/29 @ 11:31]  (2/20)

  • question about Sauron's form  <Sirinde>  [9/29 @ 11:21]  (4/26)

  • farmer giles of ham  <Sģlmaričn>  [9/29 @ 10:33]  (2/7)

  • roverrandom  <Sģlmaričn>  [9/29 @ 9:13]  (2/2)

  • Another Sauron Question  <Mandu>  [9/29 @ 8:48]  (3/8)

  • The Sword  <Mandu>  [9/29 @ 8:45]  (2/12)

  • Irrelavant Question.......  <Mandu>  [9/28 @ 19:10]  (2/3)

  • what is the differnce between.....  <tenrings>  [9/28 @ 19:03]  (3/3)

  • How did Theoden die?  <Mandu>  [9/28 @ 19:02]  (2/8)

  • PLEASE ANSWER  <Mandu>  [9/28 @ 19:01]  (5/11)

  • Shelob.  <amanda marie>  [9/28 @ 17:59]  (3/33)

  • Smith of Wooton Major  <beren_boy>  [9/28 @ 15:06]  (1/14)

  • For PhantomS: Nśmenóreans' ability to die  <NZ Strider>  [9/28 @ 12:02]  (2/9)

  • sauron question  <tenrings>  [9/28 @ 8:48]  (2/12)

  • On the proportions of the various groups of Elves to one another  <NZ Strider>  [9/28 @ 1:58]  (5/11)

  • psst Inferno *shamefully*  <EldersisofMerry>  [9/27 @ 20:09]  (2/3)

  • Q. Is there any letters or such on whether CS Lewis influenced Tolkien's ME creation...  <Nemain>  [9/27 @ 19:16]  (2/10)

  • What's IMHO?  <A man>  [9/27 @ 15:32]  (2/2)

  • Opinions respectfully rquested  <Aerlinn>  [9/27 @ 10:57]  (5/13)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #16  <Draupne>  [9/27 @ 8:55]  (15/16)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #15  <Draupne>  [9/27 @ 8:31]  (6/10)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #14 The Black Rider and farmer Maggot  <Draupne>  [9/27 @ 8:06]  (7/14)

  • Easy question, here.  <amanda marie>  [9/26 @ 16:52]  (3/12)

  • Question about Theoden  <Luthien's Mama>  [9/26 @ 16:50]  (4/6)

  • Galadriel  <BJ>  [9/26 @ 14:32]  (1/9)

  • MOS?  <cabbage'n'taters>  [9/26 @ 10:23]  (5/11)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #13 Dogs and names  <Draupne>  [9/26 @ 10:10]  (5/33)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #12 Houses and dogs  <Draupne>  [9/26 @ 9:50]  (5/12)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #11 farmers  <Draupne>  [9/26 @ 9:31]  (4/6)

  • Elvish to English dictionary?  <irpacynot>  [9/26 @ 9:15]  (1/2)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #10 Out of the wood  <Draupne>  [9/26 @ 9:07]  (5/11)

  • Maybe OT: Coincidence in "Letters"  <sundering_c>  [9/26 @ 7:31]  (3/9)

  • Bilbo and Frodo  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [9/26 @ 3:05]  (4/11)

  • The Nine  <Pukel-man>  [9/26 @ 0:53]  (3/18)

  • Need help explaining  <Taryįvėwen >  [9/25 @ 20:37]  (4/11)

  • Bored of the Rings?  <Rohwen>  [9/25 @ 15:10]  (11/15)

  • I need help with Sauron.  <Rohwen>  [9/25 @ 15:00]  (2/5)

  • More on mushrooms!  <Curious>  [9/25 @ 12:11]  (2/3)

  • Cuivienen  <Astaldo>  [9/25 @ 10:19]  (2/8)

  • What to read or not to read...  <Elwen>  [9/25 @ 7:21]  (3/5)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #9 Black Riders wailing  <Draupne>  [9/25 @ 6:00]  (10/39)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #8 more on mushrooms  <Draupne>  [9/25 @ 5:42]  (7/15)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #7  <Draupne>  [9/25 @ 3:45]  (5/18)

  • Thought I'd put up this link to something on the Home Page  <NZ Strider>  [9/25 @ 2:01]  (2/2)

  • Can we speculate Luthien is a special grace?  <Arador>  [9/24 @ 20:27]  (1/11)

  • About the Maia  <Mįme>  [9/24 @ 19:46]  (2/8)

  • I have a (maybe) silly question about Sam's family tree...  <jadeshadow>  [9/24 @ 19:11]  (3/4)

  • Saruman's ring (stop sniggering, this is the Reading Room, you know!)  <Pukel-man>  [9/24 @ 17:50]  (4/13)

  • Dwarves  <Hobbit-Of-No-Intellegence>  [9/24 @ 15:59]  (1/6)

  • For Beren Boy: On the effect of embodiment on the Istari's knowlegde  <NZ Strider>  [9/24 @ 13:45]  (1/2)

  • Hanging from Thangorodrim  <BJ>  [9/24 @ 13:40]  (2/15)

  • When Maiar are slain  <Finedhel>  [9/24 @ 12:13]  (3/13)

  • Names of the Blue Wizards?  <Temujin>  [9/24 @ 9:24]  (3/7)

  • Mines Of Moria  <Galrin, son of Gilrik>  [9/24 @ 9:17]  (4/6)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #6 The Stock-brook  <Draupne>  [9/24 @ 8:19]  (3/5)

  • Question about the Evenstar  <Athelas79>  [9/24 @ 7:07]  (2/11)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #5  <Draupne>  [9/24 @ 5:44]  (9/17)

  • A short cut to mushrooms #4  <Draupne>  [9/24 @ 5:29]  (4/9)

  • Size of the Valar  <A man>  [9/23 @ 18:31]  (6/34)

  • Bag-End  <Celanthriel>  [9/23 @ 17:07]  (5/11)

  • Concerning Elves in The Hobbit  <Lady Greenarcher>  [9/23 @ 16:43]  (1/2)

  • Inferno - about hosting a chapter discussion  <Lothirienne>  [9/23 @ 11:46]  (1/5)

  • A shortcut for mushrooms #3 Sam and Frodo  <Draupne>  [9/23 @ 10:57]  (11/13)

  • A shortcut for mushrooms #2 Pippin and Frodo  <Draupne>  [9/23 @ 10:51]  (12/19)

  • A shortcut for mushrooms #1  <Draupne>  [9/23 @ 10:47]  (9/30)

  • Arwen's Gift to Frodo  <valasarah>  [9/23 @ 10:12]  (3/8)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 29 – Belated Questions!  <Curious>  [9/23 @ 9:52]  (11/39)

  • Question about leading a chapter discussion  <Thevina Finduilas>  [9/23 @ 6:19]  (5/14)

  • greatest elf  <bilbojohnstone>  [9/23 @ 4:58]  (9/20)

  • Ainulindale question  <Nyére>  [9/23 @ 3:02]  (1/6)

  • An excellent Source  <Villordsutch>  [9/23 @ 1:58]  (1/1)

  • Regarding Gollum and aging  <Lostcause>  [9/23 @ 1:44]  (4/8)

  • Did Tolkien ever write about any of the other Elven-rings?  <Leto>  [9/22 @ 18:50]  (2/6)

  • Is Tolkien the literary Elvis . . .?  <Pukel-man>  [9/22 @ 18:29]  (4/10)

  • What has happened with Elrond's wife...  <NYC hobbit>  [9/22 @ 14:32]  (2/13)

  • The Odd Rings of Power.  <beren_boy>  [9/22 @ 13:57]  (5/9)

  • At the grey havens...  <scullysnecklace>  [9/22 @ 12:41]  (1/5)

  • the One Ring  <waterlooser>  [9/22 @ 12:36]  (1/2)

  • Mouth of sauron  <Bboy486>  [9/22 @ 11:56]  (1/4)

  • Friends theory: Sauron and Saruman brothers  <SauronLover>  [9/22 @ 9:30]  (4/10)

  • Appearance of the Silmarils  <A man>  [9/21 @ 19:59]  (5/24)

  • What was beyond the Iron hills...  <ElfLordNick>  [9/21 @ 11:30]  (2/5)

  • What to read after H, LOTR, Sil, UT, on ME? Sorry computer won't let me type in body.  (No Text)  <Rohwen>  [9/21 @ 11:00]  (6/9)

  • The BLue WIzards  <Bboy486>  [9/21 @ 8:58]  (2/8)

  • Aule  <Bboy486>  [9/21 @ 8:29]  (4/6)

  • Ungoliant  <BJ>  [9/21 @ 8:07]  (4/9)

  • Gandalf and Saruman  <Anfauglir>  [9/21 @ 7:18]  (3/3)

  • After studying Tolkien's literary devices for some months, I have only one question:  <Smokering>  [9/21 @ 0:29]  (2/5)

  • Ok, I'm not too educated on the history of Maiar and Istari.  <Sangoff>  [9/20 @ 18:27]  (2/7)

  • Full Power of the Istari  <ElfLordNick>  [9/20 @ 17:12]  (2/5)

  • Now what do I read?  <Laila>  [9/20 @ 15:28]  (2/4)

  • "The Hunt for the Ring" and "Three's Company."  <Curious>  [9/20 @ 8:01]  (6/8)

  • Was Sauron completely destroyed...  <NYC hobbit>  [9/20 @ 6:40]  (7/12)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" - Summing up  <Blue Wizard>  [9/20 @ 6:18]  (19/34)

  • Q: Wormtongue was starved by Sauruman (sharkey)...but who else feels sorry for him?  <Luthien888>  [9/20 @ 5:47]  (1/4)

  • The High Pass  <Addison>  [9/20 @ 5:36]  (3/3)

  • River of Sirion - Statues  <Villordsutch>  [9/20 @ 0:04]  (2/3)

  • Q. As a reader what makes you post with such passion in this Reading Room.  <Nemain>  [9/19 @ 23:37]  (15/40)

  • Q. Why was not Melkor made lord of the Valar?  <Nemain>  [9/19 @ 23:04]  (4/6)

  • Some more discussion fodder for "Three is Company"  <NZ Strider>  [9/19 @ 22:44]  (12/26)

  • Q. Was Melkor and Aule of the same element, that of making and forging?  <Nemain>  [9/19 @ 22:29]  (2/5)

  • Q. From what element of Melkor did the Dragons derive from?  <Nemain>  [9/19 @ 21:05]  (1/7)

  • Q. Who do you think is the most tragic character in the Silmarillion.  <Nemain>  [9/19 @ 21:02]  (5/19)

  • I just finished the trilogy...  <scullysnecklace>  [9/19 @ 18:55]  (1/7)

  • Question: Where is Long Cleeve?  <humblehobbit>  [9/19 @ 18:15]  (2/7)

  • Gandalf Vs. Balrog  <Bboy486>  [9/19 @ 17:44]  (1/6)

  • nuMENor  <Bboy486>  [9/19 @ 17:40]  (1/4)

  • Nick change  <Tar_Minastir>  [9/19 @ 16:39]  (2/5)

  • Saving Maedhros from Thangorodrim  <BJ>  [9/19 @ 13:38]  (2/2)

  • The orcs are mutated elves...  <NYC hobbit>  [9/19 @ 9:44]  (3/25)

  • HELP  <traveler11>  [9/19 @ 8:04]  (1/1)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" -  Free Discussion  <Blue Wizard>  [9/19 @ 8:00]  (4/24)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #12  -" We seem to be going the same way"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/19 @ 6:18]  (5/26)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #11 "Do Elves live in those woods?"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/19 @ 6:01]  (4/7)

  • Where is thangordrim and Gondolin located at the time of the return of the King?  (No Text)  <Luthien888>  [9/19 @ 5:50]  (2/3)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #10 "The wind's in the West"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/19 @ 5:47]  (8/23)

  • Question regarding the languages of Tolkien  <King Aragorn>  [9/18 @ 23:55]  (3/4)

  • Had Frodo ever slain anyone?  <Galathien>  [9/18 @ 20:38]  (6/19)

  • Elves ageing....  <Sangoff>  [9/18 @ 19:03]  (7/18)

  • Gollum’s Appearance  <Razanur Tuc>  [9/18 @ 19:02]  (1/3)

  • What happened to the Book Disscussion thing?  <Sangoff>  [9/18 @ 18:56]  (1/3)

  • The language of the Wild Men  <White Lady of Rohan>  [9/18 @ 18:53]  (2/3)

  • What is Thangorodrim? and...  <Bboy486>  [9/18 @ 17:07]  (3/4)

  • Question about Galadriel  <Groovicles>  [9/18 @ 14:15]  (5/10)

  • Morgoth and Fingolfin-The Spirit of Orome  <ElfLordNick>  [9/18 @ 12:18]  (5/10)

  • The Watchers & Galadriel's gifts  <Fundin>  [9/18 @ 11:55]  (5/9)

  • Please, what are grey havens?  (No Text)  <NYC hobbit>  [9/18 @ 11:44]  (4/20)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #9 " I reckon it was one of the Big Folk from foreign parts."  <Blue Wizard>  [9/18 @ 10:23]  (6/18)

  • Book I, Chapter 3, "Three is Company" #8 "A tune that was as old as the hills"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/18 @ 5:11]  (8/40)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #7 "For a short way they followed the lane westwards"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/18 @ 5:00]  (8/12)

  • Tom Bombadil ideas  <Nightfall>  [9/18 @ 4:05]  (11/16)

  • Blue Wizards  <EstelT>  [9/18 @ 3:07]  (1/1)

  • Saurman & Gandalf - Maiar  <Villordsutch>  [9/18 @ 2:14]  (1/3)

  • What is the difference? - RE: Unfinished Tales  <Villordsutch>  [9/18 @ 2:06]  (1/2)

  • For Galathien  <Villordsutch>  [9/17 @ 23:25]  (1/2)

  • Silmarillion?  <Sabian>  [9/17 @ 16:36]  (6/7)

  • OT: Other reading groups  <sundering_c>  [9/17 @ 15:55]  (1/2)

  • Help!having trouble w/download of TENGWAR translator - I have a mac - is this the problem>.....  <Luthien888>  [9/17 @ 14:43]  (2/2)

  • Who's actually the Herald of Death?  <SauronLover>  [9/17 @ 11:10]  (2/4)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #6 "'That's good for a beginning"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/17 @ 9:57]  (11/37)

  • Order of Tolkien literature.  <irpacynot>  [9/17 @ 7:44]  (1/3)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #5 "They left the washing up for Lobelia"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/17 @ 6:44]  (6/18)

  • What is so Good about the Unfinished Tales?  <Luthien888>  [9/17 @ 6:36]  (4/12)

  • Just a little poll  <Boromir The Son of Gondor >  [9/17 @ 6:23]  (24/27)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 - "Three is Company" #4 "Folco went home after lunch"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/17 @ 6:08]  (6/18)

  • Time difference issues  <Boromir The Son of Gondor >  [9/17 @ 6:06]  (3/9)

  • Boromir's prophetic dream  <Boromir The Son of Gondor >  [9/17 @ 5:57]  (1/1)

  • not sure if this  <bilbojohnstone>  [9/17 @ 4:11]  (1/2)

  • Losing your hand.  <Villordsutch>  [9/16 @ 23:50]  (1/1)

  • A book recommendation  <iowaboy>  [9/16 @ 16:43]  (6/16)

  • Arwen & Eowyn?  <Lasselanta of Mirkwood>  [9/16 @ 15:05]  (14/75)

  • I'm finished "The Silmarillion". Now what do I read?  <Hobbit-Of-No-Intellegence>  [9/16 @ 14:27]  (10/11)

  • History of Lord of the Rings question.  <Curious>  [9/16 @ 12:41]  (3/5)

  • We are attacked! Cut the bridges!  <Temujin>  [9/16 @ 10:30]  (3/6)

  • Book I, Chapter 3 "Three is Company" #3 - "I have heard something"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/16 @ 10:27]  (9/14)

  • Book I, Chapter 3: "Three is Company" #2  "It may be your task"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/16 @ 8:50]  (12/13)

  • Book I, Chapter 3, "Three is Company" - #1 "He thought as little as possible about the Ring"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/16 @ 8:45]  (12/17)

  • Annotated Hobbit: Anybody read it?  <MrCere>  [9/16 @ 8:20]  (3/6)

  • Unless ceremony shows up, I'll start "Three is Company"  <Blue Wizard>  [9/16 @ 7:53]  (5/10)

  • Eowyn Shieldmaiden-- re: Council of Elrond  <Inferno>  [9/16 @ 7:07]  (1/1)

  • Wow, I have been away for months  <El Scrocho>  [9/16 @ 6:59]  (1/1)

  • dwarves and secret names  <huorn>  [9/16 @ 6:58]  (3/3)

  • Balrog of moria  <Buckshee >  [9/16 @ 5:40]  (2/5)

  • Opinions please  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [9/16 @ 2:58]  (3/3)

  • Regarding dragons  <Kimi>  [9/16 @ 0:23]  (5/6)

  •