2002
2003
2004

  • Gandalf and the Balrog  <A man>  [9/15 @ 20:27]  (5/8)

  • Alternate endings: What if Sauron got the ring? Gandalf did not fall in Moria? etc  (No Text)  <iowaboy>  [9/15 @ 18:45]  (3/5)

  • Questions, questions, questions...  <Arwen_Undomiel>  [9/15 @ 15:27]  (4/10)

  • Istar -  Maiar - rings  <Bboy486>  [9/15 @ 11:41]  (1/4)

  • Araman  <BJ>  [9/15 @ 8:21]  (1/2)

  • Ents and Entwives....  <Arwen_2 >  [9/15 @ 6:21]  (3/4)

  • Is Ceremony out there?  <Curious>  [9/14 @ 18:50]  (1/8)

  • wierd observation...  <Astaldo>  [9/14 @ 18:08]  (8/11)

  • Sauron's title of Necromancer. Anyone know its true meaning?  <Bloody_Barnabas>  [9/14 @ 16:36]  (1/6)

  • Truth or Typo??  <Nimfarra_Baggins>  [9/14 @ 14:51]  (2/5)

  • do any of you believe?  <Sìlmarièn>  [9/14 @ 14:07]  (13/41)

  • elvish  <Sìlmarièn>  [9/14 @ 12:17]  (2/2)

  • Samwise is the " hero", not frodo!  <Sìlmarièn>  [9/14 @ 11:20]  (7/28)

  • :)  <BJ>  [9/14 @ 10:00]  (4/4)

  • Q. JRR Tolkien was Christian in spirit and heart...  <Nemain>  [9/13 @ 22:37]  (7/18)

  • Anything that made you howl with laughter?  <FattyLumpkin79>  [9/13 @ 22:17]  (3/3)

  • Q. Is the main theme of LOTR hope...  <Nemain>  [9/13 @ 21:15]  (6/11)

  • Sauron non-corporeal??  <Jackstere>  [9/13 @ 20:43]  (5/8)

  • Where is the book discussion schedule....list.....thing?  <Eowyn_Shieldmaiden>  [9/13 @ 19:23]  (2/6)

  • Q. Do you think that JRRT saw technology as modern magic  <Nemain>  [9/13 @ 17:50]  (1/2)

  • Is the lecture JRR Tokien gave "On Fairy-Stories" available on line?  (No Text)  <Nemain>  [9/13 @ 17:45]  (1/2)

  • The Nazgul:Powerful or Wimps??  <Jackstere>  [9/13 @ 17:42]  (5/20)

  • Slighly OT:   My great Ebay purchase!  <KUHNDOG81>  [9/13 @ 17:33]  (3/6)

  • Just something out of Carpenter's biography of Tolkien  <NZ Strider>  [9/13 @ 16:42]  (6/10)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 28 – Summary.  <Curious>  [9/13 @ 12:53]  (18/20)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 27 – Frodo, Gollum & Sam.  <Curious>  [9/13 @ 12:02]  (16/42)

  • what did actually happen to the Book of Mazarbul?  <SauronLover>  [9/13 @ 11:31]  (1/1)

  • How old do you think Aragorn was when he married Arwen? My guess....  <Luthien888>  [9/13 @ 11:14]  (2/2)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 26 – Sam Joins Frodo.  <Curious>  [9/13 @ 10:47]  (7/23)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 25 – Sam the Sneak.  <Curious>  [9/13 @ 8:54]  (4/16)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 24 – Sam the Gardener.  <Curious>  [9/13 @ 8:13]  (8/28)

  • THANKS YOU GUYS FOR GREAT SUGGESTIONS ON FANTASY BOOKS!!!! I am not against time travel.....but........  <Luthien888>  [9/13 @ 7:50]  (2/2)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 23 – Frodo's Dilemma.  <Curious>  [9/13 @ 4:49]  (6/18)

  • Beorns Ancestary - My argument - Big Paper  <Villordsutch>  [9/13 @ 1:58]  (3/18)

  • Just an observation from a second time reader of LOTR  <StormCrowTheGrey>  [9/13 @ 1:36]  (2/4)

  • Tom Bombadil  <Ogion The Silent>  [9/13 @ 1:16]  (2/3)

  • THANK-YOU!!!  <Trina Casey>  [9/12 @ 22:12]  (0/0)

  • Hey  <Trina Casey>  [9/12 @ 21:54]  (1/1)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 22 – Pity.  <Curious>  [9/12 @ 17:25]  (9/26)

  • The Ring leaving its owner – My little observation…  <Galathien>  [9/12 @ 15:53]  (1/4)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 21 – Stray Words.  <Curious>  [9/12 @ 13:33]  (8/25)

  • who else was in shock at the end?  <Eliadora>  [9/12 @ 13:28]  (9/10)

  • Just finished Aldarion & Erendis (The Mariner's Wife)! It made me cry.  (No Text)  <Rohwen>  [9/12 @ 11:17]  (2/5)

  • Re: Sauron-what is he?  <SauronLover>  [9/12 @ 9:31]  (2/8)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 20 – Is Gollum Undead?  <Curious>  [9/12 @ 9:09]  (8/22)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 19 – Hope.  <Curious>  [9/12 @ 7:12]  (8/22)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 18 – Gollum.  <Curious>  [9/12 @ 7:08]  (8/20)

  • melkor  <bilbojohnstone>  [9/12 @ 6:22]  (2/14)

  • Elves -possible fertility issues.......  <Luthien888>  [9/12 @ 6:22]  (2/3)

  • Gandalf - Dire Magic  <Villordsutch>  [9/12 @ 1:54]  (2/4)

  • Other Tolkien characters keen on astronomy?  <FattyLumpkin79>  [9/11 @ 21:53]  (3/7)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 17 – Sméagol.  <Curious>  [9/11 @ 21:01]  (9/31)

  • Flashback to Chapter 1 discussion - An Anachronism  <Entmaiden>  [9/11 @ 19:09]  (4/5)

  • I have a few questions...  <PrincessArwen241>  [9/11 @ 16:47]  (3/3)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 16 – The Seven.  <Curious>  [9/11 @ 14:40]  (6/23)

  • What do elves eat, how do they trade, do they have money?  (No Text)  <Rohwen>  [9/11 @ 12:21]  (2/9)

  • A thought on Gandalf and Chapter 2.  <Inferno>  [9/11 @ 11:58]  (3/10)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 15 – The Shadow.  <Curious>  [9/11 @ 11:29]  (12/35)

  • Magic Trees Anyone-Can someone Please clear up the story of all the different magic trees?  <Luthien888>  [9/11 @ 7:46]  (1/2)

  • Can anyone suggest other excellent fantasy novels??? P.S.    NO TIME TRAVEL OR MODERN DAY THROW INS  <Luthien888>  [9/11 @ 7:14]  (15/20)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 14 – The One Ring.  <Curious>  [9/11 @ 7:00]  (10/38)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 13 – Ring and Cloud.  <Curious>  [9/11 @ 6:54]  (9/25)

  • Continuing Sauron - What is he?  <Villordsutch>  [9/10 @ 23:26]  (3/35)

  • Gollum: "I am what I am"  <FattyLumpkin79>  [9/10 @ 19:45]  (1/3)

  • Concerning trolls  <Astaldo>  [9/10 @ 18:03]  (2/8)

  • Little Off Topic But...  <ElfLordNick>  [9/10 @ 16:09]  (1/2)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 12 – Saving the Shire.  <Curious>  [9/10 @ 14:21]  (16/46)

  • Elrond, tempted?  <Mister Frodo>  [9/10 @ 13:29]  (4/14)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 11 – Doubt Slept.  <Curious>  [9/10 @ 12:23]  (12/30)

  • Wizards / timeline  <Murmuran>  [9/10 @ 12:20]  (2/4)

  • Bilbo and THE Du'nadan (Aragorn)  <Luthien's Mama>  [9/10 @ 10:32]  (2/13)

  • Jumping ahead of the 'chapter' discussion, but I would like to know your thoughts on...  <Lancelot>  [9/10 @ 9:31]  (6/17)

  • Sauron - What was he?  <Villordsutch>  [9/10 @ 5:05]  (1/1)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 10 – Gandalf Reappears.  <Curious>  [9/10 @ 2:51]  (9/29)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 9 – Tree-men.  <Curious>  [9/10 @ 2:48]  (10/29)

  • Is Elrond related to Earendil, Isildur's father?  <NoneOfTheAbove>  [9/9 @ 23:46]  (4/6)

  • Hobbits and Dwarves as friends.  <cabbage'n'taters>  [9/9 @ 21:44]  (1/5)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 8 – Dwarves, No Humans.  <Curious>  [9/9 @ 18:27]  (8/19)

  • The sorcerers of Middle-earth. Just who and what were they?  <Bloody_Barnabas>  [9/9 @ 17:02]  (5/7)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 7 – Crossing the River.  <Curious>  [9/9 @ 14:34]  (14/41)

  • Unfinished Tales  <Frodosgurl>  [9/9 @ 14:24]  (1/1)

  • A meaningless question.  <Reverend>  [9/9 @ 13:58]  (2/2)

  • Sauron and his relation to the Ring  <stummies>  [9/9 @ 12:24]  (9/23)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 6 – Frodo's Life.  <Curious>  [9/9 @ 10:35]  (5/10)

  • Gandalf the White, question  <Rohwen>  [9/9 @ 10:15]  (2/5)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 5 – Elves in the Shire.  <Curious>  [9/9 @ 7:24]  (8/20)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 4 – Friends and Relatives.  <Curious>  [9/9 @ 3:07]  (6/14)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 3 – The Last Supper.  <Curious>  [9/8 @ 18:35]  (11/22)

  • About the other 16 Rings...  <Nimfalma Took>  [9/8 @ 12:47]  (1/3)

  • on Melkor and Tulkas  <Astaldo>  [9/8 @ 11:20]  (2/12)

  • Who else cries at Mt. Doom  <Eliadora>  [9/8 @ 10:23]  (14/27)

  • Beorn Problem  <A man>  [9/8 @ 9:27]  (5/32)

  • Strange what if (happened in a dream)  <Raain>  [9/8 @ 9:08]  (6/9)

  • dwarfs, where are they  <harly>  [9/8 @ 8:50]  (3/3)

  • Barad-dur  <bilbojohnstone>  [9/8 @ 5:51]  (2/4)

  • Boramir's 110 day Trek  <Luthien's Mama>  [9/7 @ 20:40]  (5/10)

  • is sam black? (my friend's theory)  <scullysnecklace>  [9/7 @ 14:35]  (7/19)

  • Opinions needed! (And I know you've got 'em! ;-D)  <Gilian Serindë>  [9/7 @ 12:33]  (3/9)

  • Why are there so few mothers in LOTR  <Lacrimae Rerum>  [9/7 @ 5:29]  (5/13)

  • sorry if this isnt allowed  <bilbojohnstone>  [9/7 @ 4:08]  (3/3)

  • A really stupid question  <A man>  [9/6 @ 20:55]  (4/11)

  • Can Anyone Translate this?  <ElfLordNick>  [9/6 @ 14:32]  (1/1)

  • How do you solve a problem like Éowyn?  <Lottelita>  [9/6 @ 12:51]  (12/38)

  • Need info on the book.  <Trina Casey>  [9/6 @ 11:49]  (1/2)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 2 – Fireside Tales.  <Curious>  [9/6 @ 8:52]  (11/36)

  • FotR: The Shadow of the Past, part 1 – Pronunciation of Names.  <Curious>  [9/6 @ 8:02]  (14/43)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Let me sum up.  <Inferno>  [9/6 @ 7:37]  (19/19)

  • a small question that's been nagging at me . . .  <Annael>  [9/6 @ 7:04]  (4/7)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Open Forum  <Inferno>  [9/6 @ 6:31]  (1/12)

  • why is the film not like the book?  <Laila>  [9/6 @ 1:43]  (7/15)

  • Sorry if I'm sounding ignorant again, but  <Caitie-the-Slightly-Ecru>  [9/5 @ 18:56]  (1/1)

  • ??'s re: Elrond and the relationship between Arwen and Aragorn  <Luthien's Mama>  [9/5 @ 17:27]  (4/19)

  • What exactly happened to Pippin when he looked into the palantir?  <Seillib>  [9/5 @ 15:52]  (3/5)

  • Hobbits, Elves and Wizards. ( Has anyone read this?)  <NoneOfTheAbove>  [9/5 @ 15:33]  (2/4)

  • On the Valar's dithering and inability to get anything done  <NZ Strider>  [9/5 @ 14:20]  (9/34)

  • Shakespeare's silly songs.  <Curious>  [9/5 @ 14:07]  (6/8)

  • TTT (sorry if I'm late)  <InterstellarPixie>  [9/5 @ 9:46]  (2/14)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Gifts  <Inferno>  [9/5 @ 7:28]  (9/15)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Three Dwarves  <Inferno>  [9/5 @ 7:23]  (13/26)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Longe Expected Party-- Bilbo gives up the Ring  <Inferno>  [9/5 @ 7:18]  (13/17)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Bilbo's Book.  <Inferno>  [9/5 @ 7:15]  (2/5)

  • For Curious: On Tolkien's villains' persuaviveness (and Tolkien's depiction thereof)  <NZ Strider>  [9/4 @ 17:19]  (3/9)

  • Question on Elrond's wife  <Celebrian of Lorien>  [9/4 @ 13:54]  (1/4)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Poetry  <Ataahua>  [9/4 @ 10:55]  (15/25)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Gandalf and the Ring  <Ataahua>  [9/4 @ 10:54]  (5/5)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Bilbo's Speech.  <Ataahua>  [9/4 @ 10:53]  (4/14)

  • On behalf of Inferno - FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Fireworks  <Ataahua>  [9/4 @ 10:52]  (6/25)

  • Where does your copy of LOTR fall open?  <Smokering>  [9/4 @ 4:29]  (10/18)

  • May be stupid but  <EldersisofMerry>  [9/3 @ 20:06]  (3/17)

  • poem  <Eliadora>  [9/3 @ 16:02]  (2/2)

  • Please read but DON'T reply!  <Curious>  [9/3 @ 15:20]  (1/1)

  • Repost from Main:  Changing my nickname.  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [9/3 @ 8:00]  (2/2)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Elves and Dragons vs. Cabbages and Potatoes.  <Inferno>  [9/3 @ 6:29]  (12/38)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Dramatis Personae  <Inferno>  [9/3 @ 6:24]  (10/37)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Victorian Life  <Inferno>  [9/3 @ 6:15]  (8/15)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Concerning Hobbits  <Inferno>  [9/3 @ 6:11]  (7/19)

  • Why did Tolkien name his novel after its archvillain?  (No Text)  <Dryhten>  [9/3 @ 3:32]  (9/11)

  • If Elrond can be called "Half-Elven," then should the Numenoreans be called Half-Elven  as well? Would that account for their extended lifespans?  (No Text)  <Dryhten>  [9/2 @ 23:30]  (4/6)

  • Tolkien's portrayal of love in the "Lay of the Children of Húrin"  <NZ Strider>  [9/2 @ 18:15]  (3/10)

  • Just an odd thought  <Nimalfa Hornblower>  [9/2 @ 17:19]  (3/6)

  • eagles or beorn  <Polly>  [9/2 @ 16:17]  (1/3)

  • can you guys read this font?  <Eliadora>  [9/2 @ 13:01]  (3/6)

  • Think back to that very first time...  <MrCere>  [9/2 @ 9:57]  (17/29)

  • Age of Aragorn  <irpacynot>  [9/2 @ 9:40]  (2/12)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- Anachronism  <Inferno>  [9/2 @ 6:58]  (13/48)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- The Ring.  <Inferno>  [9/2 @ 6:48]  (10/18)

  • FotR: Chapter One: A Long Expected Party-- The Feast  <Inferno>  [9/2 @ 6:43]  (10/18)

  • I need some help with Elvish  <BrambleroseBrandybuck>  [9/2 @ 6:37]  (3/4)

  • Opinion Question! Do you really think that there could be Elves, Dwarfs or Ents in this world?  <ElfLordNick>  [9/2 @ 6:36]  (6/6)

  • FotR: Chapter 1: A Long Expected Party -- Sequel  <Inferno>  [9/2 @ 6:24]  (14/22)

  • Grey Havens  <Orc's Bane>  [9/1 @ 19:42]  (3/9)

  • Galadriel's lightbulb  <Nimalfa Hornblower>  [9/1 @ 14:53]  (1/2)

  • apologize  <Ingwë>  [9/1 @ 14:52]  (2/2)

  • To Curious and others: Stressed syllable - recent discussion  <Galathien>  [9/1 @ 6:46]  (1/5)

  • The Two Lights in the Sil  <ElfLordNick>  [9/1 @ 6:32]  (1/1)

  •