2002
2003
2004


  • The Tuff Stuff  <Duffhackymaster>  [10/31 @ 23:54]  (5/15)

  • Language of the Third Age  <Lady Izara>  [10/31 @ 17:37]  (3/14)

  • The Steward and the King, #18: Open Discussion  <Eledhwen>  [10/31 @ 4:16]  (6/28)

  • The Steward and the King, #17: Midsummer's Eve  <Eledhwen>  [10/31 @ 4:15]  (8/9)

  • The Steward and the King, #16: The Sign  <Eledhwen>  [10/31 @ 4:12]  (7/11)

  • The Steward and the King, #15: Justice  <Eledhwen>  [10/31 @ 4:11]  (6/12)

  • Inconsistency question  <cyrano>  [10/30 @ 21:27]  (3/6)

  • The Steward and the King, #14: Out of the Great Sea  <Eledhwen>  [10/30 @ 17:36]  (5/51)

  • The Steward and the King, #13: Chinese Whispers  <Eledhwen>  [10/30 @ 17:35]  (6/7)

  • Anyone read V. Flieger's revised copy of "Splintered Light"?  <Hama of Rohan>  [10/30 @ 16:34]  (4/7)

  • Upon finishing RotK...  <elf_wannabee>  [10/30 @ 13:40]  (6/15)

  • Searching for Another Quote:  Relative Height of Rohirrim  <Cressida>  [10/30 @ 12:47]  (3/9)

  • The Steward and the King, #12: Imagery and the Stewards  <Eledhwen>  [10/30 @ 4:08]  (8/20)

  • What do you think??  <ElfatHeart>  [10/29 @ 21:10]  (5/7)

  • The Steward and the King, #11: awwwww  <Eledhwen>  [10/29 @ 16:06]  (5/23)

  • The Steward and the King, #10: *sniff*  <Eledhwen>  [10/29 @ 16:05]  (7/13)

  • Consider, what if the Line of Hurin hadn't failed with regards to Numenor?  <TheMormegil>  [10/29 @ 15:27]  (1/4)

  • the sil  <mirthandir>  [10/29 @ 10:27]  (9/14)

  • The Steward and the King, #9: Sing all ye people!  <Eledhwen>  [10/29 @ 3:59]  (9/11)

  • The Steward and the King, #8: The Stroke of Doom  <Eledhwen>  [10/29 @ 3:58]  (6/12)

  • Elvish Speaking  <EllesarTheKing>  [10/28 @ 22:39]  (5/9)

  • An errant Bombadil poem.  <NZ Strider>  [10/28 @ 21:33]  (3/6)

  • Why didn't one of the elves take the Ring to Amen...  <Downtown>  [10/28 @ 20:44]  (1/2)

  • Whos Jesus?  <Marius>  [10/28 @ 20:37]  (7/9)

  • Religion and the Silmarillion  <Gerontius>  [10/28 @ 18:32]  (11/20)

  • The Steward and the King, #7: The Fifth Day  <Eledhwen>  [10/28 @ 17:35]  (11/16)

  • The Steward and the King, #6: The Grief of Éowyn of Rohan  <Eledhwen>  [10/28 @ 17:33]  (7/9)

  • What does the name "Middle-earth" really mean?  <Darkwish>  [10/28 @ 16:11]  (4/18)

  • Roll call for November discussion leaders and note on next book discussion  <Altaira>  [10/28 @ 15:58]  (5/10)

  • Throwing the Ring into the ocean...  <Darkwish>  [10/28 @ 15:39]  (7/17)

  • The Huntsman: Thoughts on Orome  <Erudil>  [10/28 @ 10:32]  (3/7)

  • The Steward and the King, #5: *swoon*  <Eledhwen>  [10/28 @ 3:31]  (16/43)

  • Sam  < aragwen_menelothiel>  [10/27 @ 23:23]  (3/9)

  • Shelob and Smeagol  <bride_of_legolas>  [10/27 @ 23:12]  (4/15)

  • what is Gandolf?  <bride_of_legolas>  [10/27 @ 23:03]  (2/6)

  • Why the Eagles Didn't Take Frodo: My Take  <Fealdanar>  [10/27 @ 18:50]  (5/14)

  • Should the road goes ever on...?  <irpacynot>  [10/27 @ 16:48]  (8/20)

  • Is LotR a fairy-tale?  <Curious>  [10/27 @ 16:13]  (4/10)

  • The Steward and the King, #4: Éowyn on Faramir  <Eledhwen>  [10/27 @ 15:19]  (11/20)

  • The Steward and the King, #3: Faramir on Éowyn  <Eledhwen>  [10/27 @ 15:17]  (11/28)

  • Hope soon to be back  (No Text)  <Villordsutch>  [10/27 @ 14:55]  (0/0)

  • Belated question from “The Field of Cormallen.”  <Curious>  [10/27 @ 13:46]  (4/10)

  • The Steward and the King, #2: Éowyn and the Warden  <Eledhwen>  [10/27 @ 4:01]  (15/21)

  • The Steward and the King, #1: Left Behind  <Eledhwen>  [10/27 @ 4:00]  (11/13)

  • yo question  <Downtown>  [10/26 @ 22:37]  (2/2)

  • The Field of Cormallen: Summary  <Entmaiden>  [10/26 @ 21:05]  (16/18)

  • The Nameless Land  <NZ Strider>  [10/26 @ 18:42]  (4/9)

  • The Steward and the King: brief introductory note  <Eledhwen>  [10/26 @ 13:48]  (7/10)

  • suddenly noticing Goldberry  <hatster>  [10/26 @ 12:14]  (3/4)

  • second breakfast?  <stanne>  [10/26 @ 6:37]  (2/5)

  • Question about Celebrian....  <Lady Elizabeth>  [10/26 @ 4:47]  (2/5)

  • W.H. Auden and Tolkien (and some poetry)  <NZ Strider>  [10/25 @ 14:31]  (5/10)

  • The Field of Cormallen #12:  Open Discussion  <Entmaiden>  [10/24 @ 13:50]  (4/51)

  • The Field of Cormallen #11:  Time to go Home  <Entmaiden>  [10/24 @ 13:25]  (8/14)

  • Ungoliant  <Athiel>  [10/24 @ 12:32]  (4/10)

  • Belated question from "The Land of Shadow."  <Curious>  [10/24 @ 5:25]  (4/23)

  • The Field of Cormallen #10:  The Gathering of the Fellowship  <Entmaiden>  [10/23 @ 22:50]  (9/15)

  • The Field of Cormallen #9:  Great glory and splendour!  Let's have a party!  <Entmaiden>  [10/23 @ 14:04]  (6/33)

  • How does Galadriel die?  <Darkwish>  [10/23 @ 8:50]  (4/20)

  • does it matter?  <mini ring>  [10/23 @ 7:17]  (4/7)

  • The Field of Cormallen #8:  Getting Ready for the Party  <Entmaiden>  [10/22 @ 23:02]  (12/52)

  • Does anyone know the elvish "symbols" for huor or courage?  <Orthanc>  [10/22 @ 20:59]  (1/3)

  • The Field of Cormallen #7:  Reckoning Days  <Entmaiden>  [10/22 @ 20:32]  (5/20)

  • Interesting literary thread on Main  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [10/22 @ 17:52]  (0/0)

  • Adding to the poetry of Mt. Doom.  <White Gull>  [10/22 @ 12:47]  (8/10)

  • The Field of Cormallen #6:  Sam Awakens  <Entmaiden>  [10/22 @ 12:40]  (11/36)

  • The Field of Cormallen #5.  And now, over to Mt. Doom  <Entmaiden>  [10/21 @ 18:35]  (14/34)

  • The Field of Cormallen #4:  Stand, Men of the West!  <Entmaiden>  [10/21 @ 15:59]  (16/55)

  • Quick question  <nixie>  [10/21 @ 8:36]  (3/3)

  • Eru's opine...  <Double Squatamala>  [10/21 @ 6:03]  (2/3)

  • The Field of Cormallen #3:  Change is in the air  <Entmaiden>  [10/20 @ 20:51]  (14/56)

  • What are the differences between the two versions of the Gandalf - Pippin discussion about the Palantir?  <Agrippa>  [10/20 @ 17:21]  (1/2)

  • When did Gandy start to mistrust Saruman?  <Temujin>  [10/20 @ 16:17]  (2/6)

  • Disapointed in at the end of Sauron...  <Darkwish>  [10/20 @ 3:49]  (7/28)

  • The Field of Cormallen #2: The Eagles  <Entmaiden>  [10/19 @ 23:09]  (14/30)

  • The Field of Cormallen #1:  Update from the Black Gate  <Entmaiden>  [10/19 @ 22:23]  (15/24)

  • Hey just a comment  <Downtown>  [10/19 @ 21:48]  (4/4)

  • The Field of Cormallen:  Introduction  <Entmaiden>  [10/19 @ 20:08]  (6/7)

  • I have a few questions about the 3 Elven rings  <Entmaiden>  [10/19 @ 19:40]  (1/4)

  • Reading order  <Tomsk>  [10/19 @ 16:36]  (2/7)

  • Mount Doom -- Conclusion  <hatster>  [10/19 @ 10:34]  (18/27)

  • Vote for Lotr  <Galad>  [10/19 @ 9:09]  (0/0)

  • A question of time...  <Darkwish>  [10/19 @ 6:40]  (1/1)

  • Why no help in battle by the Elves?  <Darkwish>  [10/19 @ 2:41]  (2/10)

  • Denethor knew that Aragorn...  <patric44>  [10/19 @ 0:42]  (2/5)

  • Quotes from the books ... in the Movies.  <RyanR>  [10/18 @ 20:47]  (4/5)

  • Why doesn't Gollum age?  <geddy>  [10/18 @ 13:34]  (4/4)

  • The Sons of Elrond and the Paths of the Dead  <CaptainoftheDunadain>  [10/18 @ 11:01]  (2/6)

  • Wormtongue throwing the Orthanc Palantir?  <Darkwish>  [10/18 @ 6:08]  (2/10)

  • Mount Doom -- Opening the floor  <hatster>  [10/17 @ 23:26]  (6/25)

  • Mount Doom #16-- Here at the end of all things  <hatster>  [10/17 @ 19:35]  (7/24)

  • Mount Doom #15 -- It could have been like this  <hatster>  [10/17 @ 19:19]  (13/25)

  • Question on Orcs mortality, and more…  <Daughter of Nienna>  [10/17 @ 16:20]  (2/5)

  • Another neat connection between Hobbit and LOTR  <Lothirienne>  [10/17 @ 14:39]  (4/6)

  • Heroism in LOTR - Frodo and Oedipus  <Kathira>  [10/17 @ 8:19]  (3/12)

  • Mount Doom #14 -- Thy will be done  <hatster>  [10/17 @ 7:54]  (10/15)

  • Tolkien quote - cellar door?  <luinfalathiel>  [10/17 @ 0:06]  (5/6)

  • Witch King??  <IthilienRanger>  [10/16 @ 20:19]  (4/7)

  • Mount Doom #13 -- To know the mind of a hobbit  <hatster>  [10/16 @ 19:41]  (10/22)

  • Mount Doom #12--Decisions decisions  <hatster>  [10/16 @ 19:16]  (12/22)

  • Mount Doom #11 -- For pity's sake  <hatster>  [10/16 @ 7:40]  (12/55)

  • If the fellowship had remained unbroken  <Gothmog the Great>  [10/16 @ 0:18]  (7/10)

  • Many Meetings  <Gothmog the Great>  [10/16 @ 0:02]  (4/4)
  •