2002
2003
2004


  • entwives  <ash nazg01>  [11/30 @ 23:36]  (4/10)

  • Who does die in the books?  <thematrix_11>  [11/30 @ 18:11]  (4/12)

  • Barrow Wights  <BarrowBlade>  [11/30 @ 16:34]  (4/5)

  • Swords from the Barrow Downs  <BarrowBlade>  [11/30 @ 16:32]  (2/6)

  • Samwise quote  <azaeliatook>  [11/30 @ 16:31]  (1/1)

  • Discussion of Prologue Organization  <Lothirienne>  [11/30 @ 14:44]  (7/16)

  • Aragorn's travels  <kodax>  [11/30 @ 12:24]  (2/4)

  • "The Grey Havens" And that's a wrap  <CAhobbit>  [11/30 @ 4:10]  (12/16)

  • Can anyone gimme a list of Tolkein books?  <Heir_of_ Elessar>  [11/30 @ 3:27]  (3/4)

  • Haradrims Men  <ElfArcher>  [11/29 @ 16:46]  (4/6)

  • "The Grey Havens" Open discussion  <CAhobbit>  [11/29 @ 1:21]  (5/7)

  • "The Grey Havens" The End.  Roll credits.  <CAhobbit>  [11/29 @ 1:18]  (10/18)

  • "The Grey Havens" Farwell friends  <CAhobbit>  [11/29 @ 1:14]  (10/21)

  • "The Grey Havens" Cirdan and the third elven ring  <CAhobbit>  [11/29 @ 1:07]  (7/10)

  • Question on the Siege of Gondor  <patric44>  [11/28 @ 22:35]  (2/6)

  • Sindarin translation  <Lady Izara>  [11/28 @ 21:30]  (3/3)

  • elves vs. men  <kodax>  [11/28 @ 21:23]  (4/8)

  • What History of Middle Earth books would you recommend?  <LovedEveryMoment>  [11/28 @ 6:05]  (5/6)

  • A depopulated Middle Earth  <BandobrasTook>  [11/27 @ 23:04]  (1/2)

  • "The Grey Havens" Here comes that foresight again.  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 18:08]  (11/21)

  • "The Grey Havens" When your over the hill...er hobbit hole that is  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 18:05]  (9/9)

  • "The Grey Havens" Middle-Earths #1 hit  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 18:02]  (8/11)

  • So there were 7 fathers of the Dwarwes and Durin was one of them  <Erufaildon>  [11/27 @ 15:07]  (2/5)

  • Manwe vs Melkor.  <BarrowBlade>  [11/27 @ 12:56]  (3/3)

  • wait a minute, back up! What is going on !  <oathbreaker>  [11/27 @ 10:43]  (9/10)

  • What is up for discussion next?  <Rohwen>  [11/27 @ 9:56]  (2/2)

  • Is there a difference between Valar and Valinor?  <oathbreaker>  [11/27 @ 9:43]  (1/4)

  • I'm a little behind.  <oathbreaker>  [11/27 @ 8:12]  (1/3)

  • "Arwen vanimelda namarie"  <Alatariel Surion>  [11/27 @ 7:56]  (5/6)

  • "The Grey Havens" The beginning of the end  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 4:14]  (7/9)

  • "The Grey Havens" What's in a name?  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 3:47]  (7/9)

  • "The Grey Haven's" Illness  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 3:44]  (5/13)

  • "The Grey Havens" What will you be wearing this fall?  <CAhobbit>  [11/27 @ 3:40]  (10/13)

  • Elvish  <Chora011>  [11/26 @ 23:30]  (1/2)

  • Middle Earth Cook Book  <Balrog Saint>  [11/26 @ 22:19]  (2/5)

  • Fingolfin vs. Morgoth  <ElfArcher>  [11/26 @ 20:34]  (2/9)

  • Shire-Hobbits  <ElfArcher>  [11/26 @ 20:28]  (0/0)

  • Songs from the books  <Taikoboy>  [11/26 @ 20:08]  (0/0)

  • Do Hobbits bathe?  <Temujin>  [11/26 @ 19:00]  (2/4)

  • Numenor vs Valinor  <Kent>  [11/26 @ 15:44]  (9/22)

  • Legolas' Bow  <RangeroftheWild>  [11/26 @ 13:49]  (1/2)

  • Phial of Galadriel  <actionhank>  [11/26 @ 12:09]  (2/6)

  • Roll Call for December discussion leaders  <Altaira>  [11/26 @ 11:56]  (1/2)

  • Why was Angband / Utumno...  <irpacynot>  [11/26 @ 11:22]  (4/10)

  • Noteworthy Versions of LotR  <Johnny Walker>  [11/26 @ 4:51]  (0/0)

  • "The Grey Havens" Rosie you've got some 'splanin to do.  <CAhobbit>  [11/26 @ 0:47]  (8/22)

  • "The Grey Havens" It never lets go!  <CAhobbit>  [11/26 @ 0:33]  (6/7)

  • "The Grey Havens" Restoration and some neglect  <CAhobbit>  [11/26 @ 0:22]  (9/12)

  • "The Grey Havens" Need to fatten up.  <CAhobbit>  [11/25 @ 23:57]  (7/12)

  • Are there reading discussions of the Silmarillion  <Mortae>  [11/25 @ 21:44]  (3/3)

  • Question about Aule  <BarrowBlade>  [11/25 @ 20:21]  (5/10)

  • Reading Suggestions please...  <Gwaihir the Fighting Gamecock>  [11/25 @ 19:37]  (3/4)

  • Books after Return of King  <ElfArcher>  [11/25 @ 18:04]  (1/1)

  • Grima!?  <ElfArcher>  [11/25 @ 16:58]  (1/4)

  • Odd thought...  <BarrowBlade>  [11/25 @ 16:50]  (2/2)

  • Question  <oathbreaker>  [11/25 @ 9:16]  (2/5)

  • "The Grey Havens" Lobelia  <CAhobbit>  [11/25 @ 3:16]  (10/18)

  • "The Grey Havens" Fredegar Bolger  <CAhobbit>  [11/25 @ 3:12]  (11/16)

  • "The Grey Havens" You're late!  <CAhobbit>  [11/25 @ 2:57]  (7/10)

  • Referring to the people of Rohan:  A Usage Question  <hopebeam>  [11/25 @ 2:02]  (2/7)

  • Basis for the Tengwar...  <Linduin>  [11/25 @ 1:31]  (3/4)

  • elves  <abbie>  [11/24 @ 23:27]  (2/2)

  • Some Questions...  <ElfArcher>  [11/24 @ 22:57]  (2/2)

  • Dwarves and Elves  <ElfArcher>  [11/24 @ 21:15]  (2/6)

  • Who IS Tom Bombadil?  <mellúmequentalë>  [11/24 @ 19:42]  (7/12)

  • Confused! Saruman, Sauron  <ElfArcher>  [11/24 @ 17:23]  (2/5)

  • Im sure Ill be flamed for this, but...  <BarrowBlade>  [11/24 @ 16:49]  (5/15)

  • How do you visualize....  <Gwaihir the Fighting Gamecock>  [11/24 @ 15:21]  (7/7)

  • Boromir's journey -- why alone?  <Mimosa>  [11/24 @ 12:29]  (1/8)

  • My brother won't read FOTR. Persuade him! (whine)  <RurouniKJS>  [11/24 @ 12:00]  (6/6)

  • "The Grey Havens"  <CAhobbit>  [11/23 @ 23:52]  (7/15)

  • Sauron  <ElfArcher>  [11/23 @ 22:43]  (4/8)

  • Races Fates  <ElfArcher>  [11/23 @ 22:39]  (3/5)

  • Questions... questions that need answering...  (Story Spoiler - ROTK)  <Sandicomm>  [11/23 @ 22:02]  (4/6)

  • Question about the Dead in ROTK >SPOLIERS>  <Frodo24>  [11/23 @ 20:51]  (2/2)

  • Flame OF UDUN  <Inore of Aetherna>  [11/23 @ 20:43]  (2/3)

  • How do elves give up immortality?  <wizard23>  [11/23 @ 19:30]  (1/4)

  • Hobbits?  <BarrowBlade>  [11/23 @ 13:40]  (3/22)

  • "The Scouring of the Shire" Final Mop-up  <drogo_drogo>  [11/23 @ 9:57]  (15/17)

  • Tasarinan.......  <precious2004>  [11/22 @ 23:09]  (3/3)

  • Question about Hobbits  <BarrowBlade>  [11/22 @ 19:32]  (3/3)

  • Bombadil possiple origin  <BarrowBlade>  [11/22 @ 19:06]  (4/10)

  • Nazgul, Witch King, and The Mouth of Sauron  <jaylundgreen>  [11/22 @ 17:21]  (4/5)

  • "The Scouring of the Shire": "I shan't call it an end, till we've cleaned up the mess"  <drogo_drogo>  [11/22 @ 10:05]  (5/16)

  • Where's the 17 years gone?  <King Gollum>  [11/22 @ 7:01]  (2/4)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 15:  Sharkey’s End  <drogo_drogo>  [11/21 @ 19:32]  (9/12)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 14:  Wormtongue Strikes Back  <drogo_drogo>  [11/21 @ 19:24]  (8/10)

  • Oh, dear. I remind my student of Ioreth.  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [11/21 @ 19:14]  (4/5)

  • I may not be here next week.  <Curious>  [11/21 @ 17:48]  (11/12)

  • Black Gate(s)  <BarrowBlade>  [11/21 @ 17:25]  (2/2)

  • A note regarding the Scouring.  <Curious>  [11/21 @ 11:36]  (2/3)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 13:  Saruman’s Predictions  <drogo_drogo>  [11/21 @ 9:13]  (7/13)

  • The Children of Arwen and Aragorn  <Anadorn of Gondor>  [11/21 @ 4:53]  (3/27)

  • why did the elves have to leave middle-earth?  <hrpu>  [11/21 @ 4:28]  (3/9)

  • What do you plan on doing once ROTK comes out?  <ElfatHeart>  [11/20 @ 22:43]  (4/6)

  • towers of teeth  <Icanus>  [11/20 @ 21:43]  (2/2)

  • Does Tolkien categorically state that...  <elf_wannabee>  [11/20 @ 21:17]  (3/5)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 12:  Shark[ey] Attack!  <drogo_drogo>  [11/20 @ 19:48]  (9/15)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 11: “This is Mordor”  <drogo_drogo>  [11/20 @ 19:46]  (7/13)

  • the return of the king  <orion>  [11/20 @ 19:16]  (2/6)

  • Is Samwise the only non-aristocrat in the Fellowship?  <elf_wannabee>  [11/20 @ 17:31]  (6/13)

  • Arwen's choice (not what you think)  <Fisher>  [11/20 @ 10:55]  (5/9)

  • The oldest thing in ME  <Tomsk>  [11/20 @ 9:25]  (2/6)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 10:  The Battle of Bywater, the Aftermath  <drogo_drogo>  [11/20 @ 8:06]  (6/10)

  • Who in your opinion is Middle-earth's all time most dispicable traitor?  <elf_wannabee>  [11/19 @ 23:55]  (13/26)

  • characters not in LOTR movies  <BalrogBeast>  [11/19 @ 22:00]  (13/45)

  • Aragorn's End  <ComtesseDeDia>  [11/19 @ 19:42]  (5/13)

  • Pick of the words...  <Lethias>  [11/19 @ 18:55]  (1/2)

  • Boromir's journey to Imladris  <Mimosa>  [11/19 @ 16:52]  (1/1)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 9:  The Battle of Bywater  <drogo_drogo>  [11/19 @ 16:05]  (6/9)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 8:  Lobelia and her Umbrella of Vengeance  <drogo_drogo>  [11/19 @ 15:53]  (8/16)

  • voting  <Lethias>  [11/19 @ 15:37]  (1/2)

  • Here's an interesting UUT:  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Curious>  [11/19 @ 11:51]  (5/18)

  • Eowyn  <Good_Smeagol>  [11/19 @ 9:10]  (3/3)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 7:  Pimple and Sharkey Become Capitalists  <drogo_drogo>  [11/19 @ 7:53]  (8/12)

  • What page does Gandalf give the speech?  <JOEMAUS>  [11/18 @ 23:41]  (2/2)

  • Aegnor and Andreth?  <Cuthalion>  [11/18 @ 22:12]  (2/4)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 6:  The Cottons, the Tooks and the Resistance  <drogo_drogo>  [11/18 @ 18:40]  (5/34)

  • New to the RR and interested in leading a discussion?  <Altaira>  [11/18 @ 16:11]  (7/29)

  • More Books  <Lethias>  [11/18 @ 15:34]  (7/16)

  • An inconsistency in TTT  <ety3>  [11/18 @ 13:13]  (2/4)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 5:  “Shocked and Sad”  <drogo_drogo>  [11/18 @ 12:24]  (10/18)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 4:  Now Who’s Arrested Who?  <drogo_drogo>  [11/18 @ 12:22]  (8/8)

  • Sympathy for the devil?  <irpacynot>  [11/18 @ 10:56]  (3/5)

  • Free PeopleS?  <Lord Boromir>  [11/18 @ 9:45]  (1/2)

  • Did Elendil still have authority..  <patric44>  [11/18 @ 4:49]  (3/8)

  • Elves and death.  <Works of Feanor>  [11/18 @ 4:26]  (4/10)

  • The End.  <Farawyn>  [11/17 @ 21:19]  (5/10)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 3:  Shirriffs and Tom-fools  <drogo_drogo>  [11/17 @ 18:22]  (7/11)

  • orcs and elves  <soni29>  [11/17 @ 14:22]  (6/9)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire” 2:  You Can’t Go Home Again  <drogo_drogo>  [11/17 @ 8:04]  (11/16)

  • The Coming of Sheave  <NZ Strider>  [11/17 @ 3:11]  (7/17)

  • I'm sorry if this has ever been asked...  <Lady Elizabeth>  [11/17 @ 0:41]  (2/4)

  • Regarding Arwen...?  <irpacynot>  [11/16 @ 20:21]  (1/6)

  • "The Scouring of the Shire" 1:  So What's with this Chapter Anyway??  <drogo_drogo>  [11/16 @ 20:16]  (17/20)

  • What is the basis of the Elves' economy?  <Arquen>  [11/16 @ 13:11]  (7/8)

  • “The Scouring of the Shire”:  Or, The Other Saruman Chapter that Ain’t in the Movie (Intro)  <drogo_drogo>  [11/16 @ 10:42]  (10/11)
  •