2002
2003
2004


  • Helm's Deep  <ArcherOfHarad>  [12/15 @ 23:11]  (4/6)

  • Saruman and Gandalf  <ElfArcher>  [12/15 @ 22:56]  (3/10)

  • The Argonath - Question  <hartk>  [12/15 @ 16:09]  (3/4)

  • RotK Premiere and the message board system.  <Inferno>  [12/15 @ 13:20]  (2/3)

  • Appendix I iv #5:  The Wainriders  <drogo_drogo>  [12/15 @ 12:51]  (4/12)

  • Appendix A I iv #4:  The Plague and the Shadow Returns  <drogo_drogo>  [12/15 @ 12:44]  (5/11)

  • Hardback Illustrated Silmarillion  <Dinendal Vanimedle>  [12/15 @ 10:39]  (1/3)

  • Mary Poppins and Sir Walter Scott.  <Curious>  [12/15 @ 8:39]  (4/11)

  • Appendix A I iv #3:  The Kin-strife  <drogo_drogo>  [12/15 @ 7:24]  (3/4)

  • Appendix A I iv #2.  The Ship-kings and Gondor’s Golden Age  <drogo_drogo>  [12/15 @ 7:21]  (3/3)

  • Appendix A I iv #1.  The Decline and Fall (sort of) of the Gondorian Empire  <drogo_drogo>  [12/15 @ 0:28]  (6/7)

  • Elfs leaving  <ElfArcher>  [12/14 @ 23:07]  (3/4)

  • *** And the winner is:  The Hobbit  <Altaira>  [12/14 @ 20:54]  (3/3)

  • A few Questions (Orc's fate and Valar intervention during the war of the Ring)  <Alda>  [12/14 @ 20:38]  (4/17)

  • What to read next?  <Ivy Sandybanks>  [12/14 @ 18:43]  (3/5)

  • Appendices A 1 i-iii Summary  (kind of long)  <Menelwyn>  [12/14 @ 17:47]  (11/11)

  • Appendix A I iv:  Introduction  <drogo_drogo>  [12/14 @ 15:27]  (7/7)

  • Did Many of the Moriquendi Stay in Middle-earth forever?  <Finrod Felagund 5>  [12/14 @ 14:16]  (2/3)

  • morgoth's ring  <hills>  [12/14 @ 12:03]  (1/1)

  • The Day of Doom  <Finrod Felagund 5>  [12/14 @ 4:44]  (3/8)

  • 3rd way into Mordor?  <Mellonoftheelves>  [12/13 @ 22:57]  (2/3)

  • mithril versus morgul....  <greendragon>  [12/13 @ 22:04]  (5/8)

  • Fourth Age Middle Earth is Downright Depressing  <Elessar86>  [12/13 @ 21:40]  (6/6)

  • who was celaborns father  <phoenixfirelotr>  [12/13 @ 18:17]  (3/3)

  • Status of Wizards  <Muzalon>  [12/13 @ 18:03]  (3/6)

  • Isildur's to blame?  <Golfimbul>  [12/13 @ 16:14]  (4/4)

  • For some Christmas fun...  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [12/13 @ 16:08]  (1/1)

  • Was Sauron waiting for the elves to depart?  <We swears on... THE PRECIOUS!>  [12/13 @ 14:12]  (6/6)

  • Feanor question  <Rahir the Ranger>  [12/13 @ 1:03]  (2/6)

  • How is Gildor Inglorion related to Finrod?  <Amroden>  [12/12 @ 22:37]  (5/5)

  • Fate of Maedhros' Silmaril  <An_Edain>  [12/12 @ 21:08]  (2/6)

  • Appendix A 1 i-iii--Open Discussion  <Menelwyn>  [12/12 @ 12:31]  (3/8)

  • Tolkien and Hypertext  <notlost>  [12/12 @ 11:59]  (3/4)

  • In your opinion what are:  <elf_wannabee>  [12/12 @ 11:46]  (6/11)

  • Alan Lee  <Pen-Ddraig>  [12/12 @ 10:16]  (4/4)

  • Appendix A 1 iii--Final Questions  <Menelwyn>  [12/12 @ 9:56]  (4/8)

  • Appendix A 1 iii--The Return of the King  <Menelwyn>  [12/12 @ 9:56]  (3/3)

  • Is the Simmarilain worth it?  <Aeg>  [12/12 @ 5:09]  (13/15)

  • Riders of Rohan  <Balrog Saint>  [12/12 @ 0:28]  (3/5)

  • Bilbo's Disappearance  <ElfArcher>  [12/11 @ 23:19]  (4/4)

  • Traditional Silmarillion/Myths Transformed  <Tar-Telperien>  [12/11 @ 22:07]  (3/7)

  • General Silmarillion Discussion  <Prancing Pony>  [12/11 @ 21:16]  (2/5)

  • ***** Official Voting Thread For Next Book Discussion *****  <Altaira>  [12/11 @ 20:46]  (53/69)

  • what does Shelob represent  <bigidiot>  [12/11 @ 17:29]  (5/11)

  • In your opinion--who are Middle-earth's ALL ages...  <elf_wannabee>  [12/11 @ 12:49]  (8/13)

  • Appendix A 1 iii--The Snowmen  <Menelwyn>  [12/11 @ 9:32]  (6/8)

  • Lasting images  <kodax>  [12/11 @ 3:02]  (17/24)

  • Better symbol of corrupting power?  <Stewed_Rabbit>  [12/10 @ 23:08]  (9/18)

  • Favorite SUB-Characters  <ElfArcher>  [12/10 @ 22:31]  (6/8)

  • Appendix A 1 iii--The Barrow-Downs  <Menelwyn>  [12/10 @ 22:22]  (2/2)

  • Appendix A 1 iii--Wars with Angmar  <Menelwyn>  [12/10 @ 22:21]  (1/3)

  • Which LOTR book to buy?  <Ringio>  [12/10 @ 21:54]  (1/1)

  • Some questions about Ringwraiths  <Arian Ithilsar>  [12/10 @ 21:11]  (3/10)

  • In your opinion, does the Silmarillion work as a narrative?  (No Text)  <Dryhten>  [12/10 @ 19:45]  (10/12)

  • if the ring grows at will then how big can it grow?  <phoenixfirelotr>  [12/10 @ 19:31]  (1/5)

  • What book?  <Lethias>  [12/10 @ 19:29]  (1/4)

  • The Grey Havens  <BarrowBlade>  [12/10 @ 19:29]  (3/6)

  • excited....  <Lethias>  [12/10 @ 19:28]  (1/1)

  • By-products of reading appendix A  <White Gull>  [12/10 @ 12:35]  (4/5)

  • Post Fall of Sauron Evil  <Muzalon>  [12/10 @ 10:12]  (1/9)

  • Appenix A 1 iii--Eriador and Arnor  <Menelwyn>  [12/10 @ 9:52]  (1/1)

  • appendix A I 2--The Realms in Exile  <Menelwyn>  [12/10 @ 9:51]  (3/3)

  • Just to show i should write things down  <Balrog Saint>  [12/10 @ 6:46]  (1/1)

  • Broken Blades in Lord of the Rings  <Song of Eru>  [12/10 @ 4:27]  (6/7)

  • Appendix A 1 i--After the Fall  <Menelwyn>  [12/9 @ 22:18]  (7/11)

  • Are the appendices more than a game?  <Curious>  [12/9 @ 12:55]  (13/33)

  • hobbits/Eru?  <laughingmood>  [12/9 @ 12:46]  (4/11)

  • Appendix A 1 i--The Fall of Numenor  <Menelwyn>  [12/9 @ 9:54]  (8/16)

  • Why was Gilgalad High King Of The Noldor?  <irpacynot>  [12/9 @ 2:05]  (5/8)

  • Argh! This is driving me nuts! Help with hobbits...  <pria>  [12/9 @ 1:46]  (4/5)

  • Help from you lord of the rings enthusiasts  <JoJoMaus>  [12/8 @ 22:26]  (2/4)

  • Appendix A 1 i--The Decline of Numenor  <Menelwyn>  [12/8 @ 21:59]  (6/9)

  • Appendix A 1 i--Numenor background  <Menelwyn>  [12/8 @ 21:58]  (4/12)

  • need help w/ two things  <bigidiot>  [12/8 @ 16:40]  (2/2)

  • Andróg Question  <Torpkid>  [12/8 @ 15:21]  (1/1)

  • Appendix A 1 i--The Halfelven  <Menelwyn>  [12/8 @ 12:06]  (5/9)

  • Appendix A 1 i--Earendil  <Menelwyn>  [12/8 @ 12:06]  (7/11)

  • UK editions of Tolkien's HoME seris  <Whats_Real>  [12/8 @ 1:14]  (1/2)

  • Appendix A 1 i--some thematic issues  <Menelwyn>  [12/7 @ 22:32]  (6/12)

  • Appendix A 1 i--general questions  <Menelwyn>  [12/7 @ 22:30]  (10/16)

  • The Hobbit  <Creamy>  [12/7 @ 22:28]  (4/5)

  • Just Wondering about the Witch King  <Downtown>  [12/7 @ 20:31]  (2/4)

  • Who is to blame for the Scouring of the Shire?  <Taikoboy>  [12/7 @ 19:16]  (6/9)

  • Appendices A I i-iii Overview (a little early)  <Menelwyn>  [12/6 @ 23:18]  (12/12)

  • Book prices for The History of Middle Eart  <Whats_Real>  [12/6 @ 21:58]  (2/4)

  • Gandalf VS the Balrog (its a long one)  <Balrog Saint>  [12/6 @ 20:53]  (4/4)

  • Prologue: Summary  <Lothirienne>  [12/6 @ 16:37]  (14/14)

  • Noteworthy publications of LotR  <Johnny Walker>  [12/6 @ 8:51]  (2/4)

  • Shape shifting?  <irpacynot>  [12/5 @ 17:19]  (3/10)

  • The Red Book  <wishilookedlikearwen >  [12/5 @ 15:39]  (2/8)

  • Witch King  <glorifindel>  [12/5 @ 12:54]  (2/5)

  • Prologue: Open Discussion  <Lothirienne>  [12/5 @ 10:28]  (6/25)

  • Note on Shire Records # 4  <Lothirienne>  [12/5 @ 0:34]  (4/4)

  • Note on the Shire Records # 3  <Lothirienne>  [12/5 @ 0:28]  (3/3)

  • Note on the Shire Records #2  <Lothirienne>  [12/5 @ 0:21]  (5/6)

  • Gollum - ?? Once a Hobbit or Not ??  <Danboy>  [12/5 @ 0:20]  (2/6)

  • Note on the Shire Records # 1  <Lothirienne>  [12/5 @ 0:14]  (2/6)

  • Lord of the Rings in HTML  <LOTR_ebooks>  [12/4 @ 20:42]  (1/1)

  • Arwen's gift to Frodo - what was it?  (Story Spoiler - RotK)  <Lord Madhammer>  [12/4 @ 17:16]  (2/16)

  • Glorfindel : Dead or Alive?  <Bythedar>  [12/4 @ 14:18]  (2/4)

  • Of the Finding of the Ring # 3  <Lothirienne>  [12/4 @ 2:35]  (6/10)

  • Of the Finding of the Ring # 2  <Lothirienne>  [12/4 @ 2:29]  (5/9)

  • Of the Finding of the Ring # 1  <Lothirienne>  [12/4 @ 2:20]  (10/13)

  • Norse Myth...  <Inore of Aetherna>  [12/3 @ 21:17]  (9/33)

  • Silmarillion  <valkirk>  [12/3 @ 17:10]  (1/1)

  • Frodo and Faramir  <Fisher>  [12/3 @ 14:04]  (4/6)

  • Upon the immediate conclusion of the...  <elf_wannabee>  [12/3 @ 13:35]  (5/6)

  • Of the Ordering of the Shire # 3  <Lothirienne>  [12/3 @ 0:52]  (6/9)

  • of the Ordering of the Shire #2  <Lothirienne>  [12/3 @ 0:41]  (6/10)

  • Of the Ordering of the Shire # 1  <Lothirienne>  [12/3 @ 0:35]  (6/13)

  • Thoughts on the Dunedain  <Erudil>  [12/2 @ 23:56]  (7/34)

  • Question about what order to Read...  <Downtown>  [12/2 @ 22:00]  (2/6)

  • Denethor  <ElfArcher>  [12/2 @ 18:50]  (3/4)

  • Necromancer  <Eárend>  [12/2 @ 17:44]  (4/4)

  • Arrival of the Istari  <ety3>  [12/2 @ 14:49]  (1/7)

  • Future works?  <Bruinhoov>  [12/2 @ 14:22]  (2/5)

  • Anyone glad that there are differences...  <elf_wannabee>  [12/2 @ 12:47]  (11/24)

  • Healers in Gondor  <Taikoboy>  [12/2 @ 3:01]  (5/5)

  • Concerning Pipeweed # 4  <Lothirienne>  [12/2 @ 2:12]  (3/25)

  • Concerning Pipeweed # 3  <Lothirienne>  [12/2 @ 2:08]  (7/13)

  • Concerning Pipeweed #2  <Lothirienne>  [12/2 @ 2:03]  (7/8)

  • Concerning Pipeweed # 1  <Lothirienne>  [12/2 @ 2:00]  (7/32)

  • Disturbing portion  <kodax>  [12/2 @ 1:29]  (5/5)

  • Who are our oldest readers here?  <squire>  [12/1 @ 18:39]  (8/13)

  • Gimli and the Gilittering caves  <Inore of Aetherna>  [12/1 @ 16:07]  (2/2)

  • Think Luke's like Beren? or Turin?  <RangeroftheWild>  [12/1 @ 13:25]  (5/6)

  • main character  <ent_friend>  [12/1 @ 7:36]  (3/8)

  • sadness  <ent_friend>  [12/1 @ 7:34]  (5/8)

  • Book Question  <BoromirFan>  [12/1 @ 5:43]  (1/1)

  • Concerning Hobbits # 6  <Lothirienne>  [12/1 @ 3:18]  (7/7)

  • Concerning Hobbits # 5  <Lothirienne>  [12/1 @ 3:13]  (7/10)

  • Concerning Hobbits # 4  <Lothirienne>  [12/1 @ 3:08]  (1/8)

  • Concerning Hobbits # 3  <Lothirienne>  [12/1 @ 2:43]  (4/17)

  • Concerning Hobbits # 2  <Lothirienne>  [12/1 @ 2:37]  (7/10)

  • Prologue: Concerning Hobbits # 1  <Lothirienne>  [12/1 @ 2:34]  (7/9)

  • Dwarven battle-cry?  <Nevrast>  [12/1 @ 1:10]  (2/2)
  •