2002
2003
2004


  • TTT Book III: Chapter 8-- What's going on? Orc-slaying and The Glittering Caves  <Inferno>  [4/15 @ 21:31]  (10/20)

  • TTT Book III: Chapter 8-- Deus ex machina and The quality of Mercy  <Inferno>  [4/15 @ 21:29]  (8/22)

  • TTT Book III: Chapter 8, The Road to Isengard-- Revisiting the past:  <Inferno>  [4/15 @ 21:28]  (5/11)

  • K guys, simple question...  <Yncanes>  [4/15 @ 19:54]  (3/14)

  • I have tried to read Silmarillion twice now and failed...  <Cheshire Cat>  [4/15 @ 16:23]  (14/26)

  • To anyone who has read both Beowulf and Tolkien's essay on it  <Dryhten>  [4/15 @ 15:58]  (0/0)

  • Thanks to all who helped me  <kat_mulder>  [4/15 @ 11:46]  (0/0)

  • Thank you, Atlas, for leading last week's discussion!  <Curious>  [4/15 @ 8:55]  (11/11)

  • Helm's Deep: what I love about this chapter.  <Curious>  [4/15 @ 8:48]  (6/30)

  • Wars after Sauron  <patric44>  [4/15 @ 4:11]  (1/1)

  • JK Rowling and Tolkien  <Lady Aredhel 333>  [4/15 @ 0:09]  (7/19)

  • A humble request for some pronunciation clarification . . .  <Pukel-man>  [4/14 @ 23:27]  (2/15)

  • Prophesy or Fate  <kodax>  [4/14 @ 21:48]  (4/15)

  • chapter question  <drogo_drogo>  [4/14 @ 19:39]  (2/7)

  • Gandalf, the ring-bearer  <menewbie>  [4/14 @ 15:11]  (1/2)

  • a question of the shire calendar  <FantasyFan>  [4/14 @ 14:23]  (0/0)

  • Alternate Galadriels  <Princess of Geekland>  [4/14 @ 12:01]  (5/15)

  • Strictly...what could have been  <PhantomS>  [4/14 @ 11:34]  (4/4)

  • I've always wondered...  <precious2004>  [4/14 @ 5:54]  (3/4)

  • What would have happened if...  (Story Spoiler - Return of the King)  <OregonTolkienFan>  [4/13 @ 23:57]  (7/9)

  • I'm back.  <ThorondorEagleofManwė>  [4/13 @ 20:07]  (3/3)

  • Gothmog -- The Silmarillion...b  <Lord-Smeagol>  [4/13 @ 18:30]  (2/3)

  • Did Rory Brandybuck live on Bagshot Row?  <arrowroot son of arrowshirt>  [4/13 @ 17:21]  (4/8)

  • A Palantir Question  <PhantomS>  [4/13 @ 11:42]  (1/32)

  • Another Helm's Deep chapter question...  <Dame Ioreth >  [4/13 @ 10:02]  (6/18)

  • Do you think the Silmarillion...  <OregonTolkienFan>  [4/13 @ 0:33]  (5/32)

  • An Istari quandry  <PhantomS>  [4/12 @ 19:48]  (2/11)

  • Galadriel and Shelob  <Dryhten>  [4/12 @ 13:33]  (4/24)

  • question about Elven grammar....  <Lady Elizabeth>  [4/11 @ 22:14]  (3/4)

  • I just read the original ending to LOTR - how beautiful!  <Bree Baggins>  [4/11 @ 21:10]  (3/7)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #18  <Atlas>  [4/11 @ 20:41]  (4/13)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #17  <Atlas>  [4/11 @ 20:30]  (11/14)

  • The many faces of Sauron  <Olmazh the Destroyer>  [4/11 @ 14:56]  (5/6)

  • Questions that need answering  <Princess of Geekland>  [4/11 @ 12:29]  (0/0)

  • Gimli vs. Men  <Golfimbul>  [4/11 @ 12:11]  (4/7)

  • Looking for a spot in LOTR  <kat_mulder>  [4/11 @ 12:05]  (2/5)

  • The return of Melkor?  <Goffer_the_foul_orc>  [4/11 @ 8:03]  (1/4)

  • Mouth of Sauron - Who be he...could he be  <Villordsutch>  [4/11 @ 5:29]  (3/6)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #16  <Atlas>  [4/11 @ 3:20]  (7/8)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #15  <Atlas>  [4/11 @ 3:11]  (8/12)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #14  <Atlas>  [4/11 @ 3:05]  (9/13)

  • Tolkien, CS Lewis, Phillip Pullman, and the value of metaphor  <Dryhten>  [4/10 @ 13:05]  (4/38)

  • Helm's Deep: another inconsistency.  <Curious>  [4/10 @ 8:01]  (1/4)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #13  <Atlas>  [4/10 @ 3:26]  (7/15)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #12  <Atlas>  [4/10 @ 2:44]  (9/13)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #11  <Atlas>  [4/10 @ 2:39]  (8/17)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #10  <Atlas>  [4/10 @ 2:28]  (9/13)

  • Help!  <alissabaggins>  [4/10 @ 0:40]  (1/6)

  • A new Biblical Reference  <Celebdil>  [4/9 @ 22:08]  (5/23)

  • Iluvatar's intentions  <Syllona>  [4/9 @ 20:04]  (1/10)

  • Project Firu  <Tim_the_White>  [4/9 @ 19:01]  (1/2)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #9  <Atlas>  [4/9 @ 3:50]  (10/20)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #8  <Atlas>  [4/9 @ 3:04]  (9/19)

  • Armageddon and LOTR similarities?  <patric44>  [4/9 @ 2:31]  (4/5)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #7  <Atlas>  [4/9 @ 2:21]  (9/12)

  • Dwarves  <rangers rule>  [4/8 @ 14:13]  (6/34)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #6  <Atlas>  [4/8 @ 3:25]  (6/11)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #5  <Atlas>  [4/8 @ 2:57]  (10/28)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #4  <Atlas>  [4/8 @ 2:33]  (8/10)

  • Wizard Color Interpretation  <Eternal Spirit>  [4/8 @ 1:17]  (8/16)

  • Men and Mandos  <WraithofESM>  [4/8 @ 0:29]  (2/10)

  • Ok, new in the RR, got sorta a dumb question for you...  <Arian Ithilsar>  [4/7 @ 20:58]  (4/4)

  • Chapter Discussion leaders for April  <Inferno>  [4/7 @ 15:14]  (1/1)

  • Actually about the 2 blue wizards and Istari rank  <Reddevil>  [4/7 @ 8:22]  (1/11)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep  <Atlas>  [4/7 @ 3:04]  (6/9)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #2  <Atlas>  [4/7 @ 2:44]  (13/16)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep #1  <Atlas>  [4/7 @ 2:36]  (3/7)

  • alligence  <Ring's wrath>  [4/7 @ 1:16]  (6/11)

  • Small question about Rangers.  <Aldebaran>  [4/7 @ 0:50]  (6/10)

  • This may be a stupid question with an obvious answer...  <Frodo_for_President>  [4/7 @ 0:36]  (1/6)

  • Gandalf's Imprisonment  <A man>  [4/7 @ 0:21]  (4/5)

  • Book III, Chapter vii: Helm's Deep Preface  <Atlas>  [4/6 @ 16:11]  (1/1)

  • Book 3 Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" My belated summary  <Morwen>  [4/6 @ 15:36]  (18/19)

  • who are th 5 istari?  <lexaqua>  [4/6 @ 4:35]  (2/2)

  • Lives of the Elves..  (Story Spoiler)  <Sirithdarion>  [4/6 @ 3:27]  (2/7)

  • Regarding Tom Bombadil  <Psyphon>  [4/6 @ 1:12]  (4/56)

  • quick question  <Frodo_for_President>  [4/6 @ 0:33]  (2/7)

  • Gandalf the Maia  <ranger in ithilien>  [4/5 @ 19:36]  (4/7)

  • Literary words.  <Farawyn>  [4/4 @ 23:02]  (13/23)

  • A question about Galadriel and Feanor?  <Bonomir>  [4/4 @ 18:46]  (5/13)

  • Why, O Why is Mount Doom so short?!?  <samwise the fat>  [4/4 @ 17:54]  (3/6)

  • Something I've always wondered about....  <Frodo_for_President>  [4/4 @ 17:17]  (5/17)

  • What is the best book about Tolkien  <Ulmo89>  [4/4 @ 15:43]  (2/2)

  • 2 fun things I just learned  <Princess of Geekland>  [4/4 @ 13:56]  (1/6)

  • Wormtongue spitting.  <Golfimbul>  [4/4 @ 13:38]  (2/10)

  • "The King of the Golden Hall" -- additional question.  <Curious>  [4/4 @ 9:52]  (7/47)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #26  <Morwen>  [4/4 @ 8:45]  (4/6)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #25  <Morwen>  [4/4 @ 8:41]  (3/6)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #24  <Morwen>  [4/4 @ 8:38]  (3/3)

  • Unpublished material  <Nimbrethil>  [4/4 @ 5:14]  (5/10)

  • Can't for the life of me remember who administers the Chapter Discussions...  <Aerlinn>  [4/4 @ 4:20]  (1/1)

  • Hobbits and big feet  <gullygilly>  [4/3 @ 22:51]  (11/30)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #23  <Morwen>  [4/3 @ 20:58]  (5/8)

  • Book 3, Ch.6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #22  <Morwen>  [4/3 @ 20:53]  (10/31)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #21  <Morwen>  [4/3 @ 20:47]  (6/8)

  • Three Elvish Questions  <Turin00>  [4/3 @ 19:43]  (1/1)

  • Entwives  <Quickbeam2003>  [4/3 @ 17:21]  (1/6)

  • A question that's been bugging me...  <NoneOfTheAbove>  [4/3 @ 16:48]  (4/4)

  • Could someone check my facts, please?  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [4/3 @ 14:38]  (7/15)

  • Middle Earth is beautiful...  <Murmuran>  [4/3 @ 14:00]  (15/26)

  • Helms Deep  <Nimbrethil>  [4/3 @ 10:01]  (2/5)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #20  <Morwen>  [4/3 @ 9:26]  (8/14)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" # 19  <Morwen>  [4/3 @ 9:23]  (5/6)

  • Book 3, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" (and an apology)  <Morwen>  [4/3 @ 9:16]  (8/9)

  • OT: Absence  <NZ Strider>  [4/3 @ 3:27]  (13/15)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #17  <Morwen>  [4/2 @ 21:11]  (4/9)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #16  <Morwen>  [4/2 @ 21:07]  (10/28)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #15  <Morwen>  [4/2 @ 21:02]  (5/8)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #13  <Morwen>  [4/2 @ 9:32]  (6/12)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall" #14  <Morwen>  [4/2 @ 9:26]  (6/8)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #12  <Morwen>  [4/2 @ 9:19]  (3/6)

  • The ring gives power according to its wearer.  <Reddevil>  [4/2 @ 7:14]  (3/5)

  • Questions  <patric44>  [4/2 @ 1:41]  (2/4)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #11  <Morwen>  [4/1 @ 20:30]  (7/12)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #10  <Morwen>  [4/1 @ 20:27]  (5/13)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #9  <Morwen>  [4/1 @ 20:23]  (6/7)

  • Chapter 6: The Battle of the Pelennor Fields  <Cyberia>  [4/1 @ 18:14]  (3/5)

  • pick a character  <Frodo_for_President>  [4/1 @ 17:27]  (27/63)

  • Legolas and Gimli  <Son of Thranduil>  [4/1 @ 15:27]  (2/4)

  • two allegorical themes?  <bigidiot>  [4/1 @ 14:39]  (5/28)

  • The movie in your head...  <Dame Ioreth >  [4/1 @ 12:34]  (7/8)

  • "Collate Replies" rocks!  <Curious>  [4/1 @ 11:26]  (3/3)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #8  <Morwen>  [4/1 @ 9:22]  (9/18)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #7  <Morwen>  [4/1 @ 9:19]  (9/17)

  • Book 2, Ch. 6 "The King of the Golden Hall"  #6  <Morwen>  [4/1 @ 9:17]  (7/13)

  • About the dwarves...  <precious2004>  [4/1 @ 8:49]  (3/3)

  • Gondor & Rohan  <Villordsutch>  [4/1 @ 7:56]  (3/6)

  • Im Hungry  <kodax>  [4/1 @ 1:45]  (5/6)

  • Need help with a Tolkien related crossword question  <flyerec>  [4/1 @ 1:15]  (1/2)

  •