2002
2003
2004


  • Just curious...(but not Curious!)  <Farawyn>  [5/15 @ 20:08]  (10/22)

  • The Taming of Smeagol 5  <Nimfalma Took>  [5/15 @ 19:56]  (8/21)

  • The Taming of Smeagol 4  <Nimfalma Took>  [5/15 @ 16:39]  (6/23)

  • Tolkien virgin report on Main  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [5/15 @ 15:58]  (7/10)

  • Suppose Aragorn is with Frodo at the Cracks of Doom  <nerdanel50>  [5/15 @ 13:16]  (6/19)

  • Something Aragorn says in ROTK?  <Lancelot>  [5/15 @ 10:52]  (5/5)

  • Bilbo's Mithril Mail  <Thorongil2931>  [5/14 @ 22:53]  (3/20)

  • Thranduil  <kodax>  [5/14 @ 22:32]  (2/11)

  • The Nazgul in the Second Age  <Bonomir>  [5/14 @ 20:03]  (3/31)

  • The eye of Sauron  <mallorn leaf>  [5/14 @ 12:58]  (6/33)

  • Orome's hunting expeditions  <PhantomS>  [5/14 @ 8:00]  (1/4)

  • For those who participated in the "Are dwarfs Neanderthals" thread  <Draupne>  [5/14 @ 5:22]  (3/4)

  • The One  <JTelcontar>  [5/13 @ 19:24]  (6/24)

  • The nature of the seven?  <Orome85>  [5/13 @ 18:04]  (2/15)

  • Getting confused...  <Mallothwen>  [5/13 @ 17:04]  (2/3)

  • Taming of Smeagol 3  <Nimfalma Took>  [5/13 @ 15:32]  (8/29)

  • Outta here.  <Reverend>  [5/13 @ 15:29]  (28/29)

  • The Races of Men  <The Bombastic Sophist>  [5/13 @ 15:22]  (4/13)

  • Bombadillion?  <irpacynot>  [5/13 @ 14:11]  (4/8)

  • The Return of the Shadow?  <Isembard>  [5/13 @ 11:11]  (2/3)

  • Eureka!  <Reverend>  [5/13 @ 10:50]  (2/2)

  • Tolkien with tongue in cheek?  <hatster>  [5/12 @ 22:44]  (5/13)

  • Who is Glorfindel  <Orome85>  [5/12 @ 20:33]  (2/4)

  • Aragorn's age?  <JTelcontar>  [5/12 @ 20:09]  (3/14)

  • How is Mirkwood different......  <patric44>  [5/12 @ 19:51]  (5/6)

  • the nature of Tom Bombadil  <Orome85>  [5/12 @ 19:46]  (5/25)

  • The Taming Of Smeagol Part 2  <Nimfalma Took>  [5/12 @ 16:30]  (8/16)

  • Drumroll please: "The Taming of Smeagol" Part 1  <Nimfalma Took>  [5/12 @ 16:18]  (9/12)

  • LoTR vs. Narnia  <The Bombastic Sophist>  [5/12 @ 15:38]  (3/8)

  • Prince Imrahil  <Thevina Finduilas>  [5/12 @ 14:02]  (2/4)

  • Choice of Immortality  (Story Spoiler)  <Gourry>  [5/12 @ 12:32]  (3/9)

  • Legolas age?  <Mellonoftheelves>  [5/10 @ 22:11]  (6/17)

  • Downfall of the Elves?  <Goffer_the_Sindar>  [5/10 @ 19:20]  (4/7)

  • Elven Maidens can't be warriors?  <the_hobbit_girl>  [5/10 @ 16:19]  (9/16)

  • I have this copy of RotK....  <Uruk-Katie>  [5/10 @ 13:10]  (4/10)

  • elvish poem  <snarlin' orc>  [5/10 @ 5:50]  (2/9)

  • Legolas ???help  <Rahir the Ranger>  [5/10 @ 1:23]  (4/8)

  • Christian and other symbolism  <Princess of Geekland>  [5/9 @ 14:38]  (6/95)

  • The Palantķr: #15 - summary, long  <Eledhwen>  [5/9 @ 12:57]  (23/24)

  • The Palantķr: #14 - anything I've missed?  <Eledhwen>  [5/9 @ 11:55]  (1/6)

  • The Palantķr: #13 - Gandalf etc.  <Eledhwen>  [5/9 @ 11:54]  (6/12)

  • Family Tree question  <Lorien-lover>  [5/8 @ 22:13]  (4/10)

  • Sort of very OT: George MacDonald  <Sandicomm>  [5/8 @ 20:44]  (1/3)

  • Why are the elves leaving?  <Xela>  [5/8 @ 17:51]  (5/30)

  • question 2 - the shadow of the past.  <Amatire>  [5/8 @ 15:58]  (3/14)

  • I know we are on the palantir right now, but..  <Amatire>  [5/8 @ 15:46]  (5/8)

  • The Palantķr: #12 - Those that watch from afar  <Eledhwen>  [5/8 @ 11:41]  (5/5)

  • The Palantķr: #11 - What If ...?  <Eledhwen>  [5/8 @ 11:39]  (13/16)

  • The Palantķr: #10 - Aragorn and the Stone  <Eledhwen>  [5/8 @ 11:37]  (8/13)

  • Gimli and Galadriel  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [5/8 @ 9:00]  (6/11)

  • A question about Saruman/Curumo.  <Aldebaran>  [5/7 @ 15:08]  (3/5)

  • The Palantir: #9 - Pebbles  <Eledhwen>  [5/7 @ 10:36]  (7/8)

  • The Palantir: #8 - what was Pippin seeing?  <Eledhwen>  [5/7 @ 10:35]  (12/21)

  • The Palantir: #7 - Healing  <Eledhwen>  [5/7 @ 10:34]  (8/26)

  • I'm new here!  <ZinniaB>  [5/7 @ 1:42]  (3/3)

  • The Palantir: #6 - Pippin's vision  <Eledhwen>  [5/6 @ 13:48]  (7/21)

  • Frodo in Valinor  <SilvanElfLord>  [5/6 @ 13:39]  (2/10)

  • What are all the names for Aragorn?  <Isembard>  [5/6 @ 13:05]  (2/10)

  • Chapter Discussion Leaders for May and Chapter Sign-up Thread  <Inferno>  [5/6 @ 11:24]  (15/16)

  • The Palantir: #5 - Meddling in the Affairs of Wizards  <Eledhwen>  [5/6 @ 9:56]  (7/12)

  • The Palantķr: #4 - the Growth of Hobbits  <Eledhwen>  [5/6 @ 4:46]  (6/8)

  • Tulkas - Tom Bombadil  <IBo>  [5/6 @ 4:31]  (5/12)

  • Aragorn's and Arwen's son continue line of Gondor?  <patric44>  [5/6 @ 1:26]  (3/12)

  • A Quick Pardon Me  <Nimfalma Took>  [5/5 @ 20:22]  (1/2)

  • The Palantķr: #3 - rolling hills  <Eledhwen>  [5/5 @ 12:18]  (6/19)

  • The Palantķr: #2 - dangling rag-tags  <Eledhwen>  [5/5 @ 12:17]  (13/26)

  • The Palantķr: #1  <Eledhwen>  [5/5 @ 12:15]  (12/16)

  • Prince Imrahil  <Thorongil2931>  [5/5 @ 10:26]  (5/10)

  • The Voice of Saruman:  Wrapping Up  <lumpkin>  [5/5 @ 2:10]  (15/16)

  • The Talisman (King and Straub)  <Sabrinaleena>  [5/4 @ 20:17]  (3/6)

  • A few questions on Balrogs...  <lotr elentari>  [5/4 @ 17:32]  (4/9)

  • Are orcs imortal?  <person>  [5/4 @ 14:42]  (5/8)

  • How grim is grim?  <PhantomS>  [5/4 @ 10:14]  (4/9)

  • On Orcs  <Sandicomm>  [5/3 @ 19:07]  (5/7)

  • Killing and Smeagol  <Thranduil II>  [5/3 @ 17:02]  (3/10)

  • Similar Fiction  <vgunn>  [5/3 @ 11:09]  (8/15)

  • Taters  <twisp>  [5/3 @ 2:28]  (4/8)

  • JRRT & English Myths  <Thistlethorn>  [5/2 @ 16:48]  (3/7)

  • The Voice of Saruman #15  Saruman’s Place in the History of the Third Age  <lumpkin>  [5/2 @ 13:43]  (5/5)

  • The Voice of Saruman # 14 More Loose Ends and Some Fun  <lumpkin>  [5/2 @ 13:33]  (9/12)

  • The Voice of Saruman:  #13 The Fateful Choice of a Projectile  <lumpkin>  [5/2 @ 13:30]  (13/20)

  • The Voice of Saruman #12 Of the Istari  <lumpkin>  [5/1 @ 13:15]  (7/27)

  • The Voice of Saruman #11  His Staff Is Broken  <lumpkin>  [5/1 @ 13:11]  (10/16)

  • The Voice of Saruman #10:  Saruman Turns His Attention to Gandalf  <lumpkin>  [5/1 @ 13:07]  (12/18)

  • Inferno,  TTT chapter request inside  <hatster>  [5/1 @ 7:53]  (1/4)

  • Extra reading on Aragorn's rule of Gondor and Arnor  <patric44>  [5/1 @ 0:57]  (1/2)

  •