2002
2003
2004


  • IV.5.  The Window on the West – 14.  Summary/wrap-up  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/15 @ 21:24]  (16/17)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 13.  Open comments  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/15 @ 13:04]  (5/44)

  • The Forbidden Pool: Introduction and Waxing Poetic  <hatster>  [6/15 @ 10:32]  (7/14)

  • HIgher and Lower Beings  <Cressida>  [6/15 @ 0:42]  (7/15)

  • Basic Question  <New Reader>  [6/14 @ 22:32]  (10/19)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 12.  Sam lets his tongue slip  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/14 @ 10:41]  (10/35)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 11.  Elves  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/14 @ 10:23]  (8/37)

  • Geography and structures  <Bboy486>  [6/14 @ 2:21]  (4/12)

  • Recurring theme  <Bboy486>  [6/14 @ 2:18]  (3/4)

  • Gondorian Titles  <Lira_Jaerene>  [6/13 @ 17:43]  (6/13)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 10.  Necessity  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/13 @ 16:32]  (10/18)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 9.  Quest for immortality  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/13 @ 16:26]  (8/10)

  • Hats off to Christopher  <Murmuran>  [6/13 @ 13:05]  (2/12)

  • "Gondor has no king. Gondor needs no king."  <Golfimbul>  [6/13 @ 1:50]  (4/11)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 8.  The refuge of Henneth Annūn  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/12 @ 21:14]  (12/22)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 7.  Faramir’s hopes  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/12 @ 21:10]  (9/24)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 6.  Mithrandir  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/12 @ 0:51]  (10/19)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 5.  Stewardship/Kingship  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/12 @ 0:48]  (19/48)

  • Silmarillion Questions  <Alveric>  [6/11 @ 15:50]  (3/15)

  • Question about Witchking etc.  <snowdropper>  [6/11 @ 15:20]  (3/10)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 4.  An improbable recognition?  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/11 @ 10:11]  (8/16)

  • Sauron. And another name.  <Eowyn_Child_Of_Destiny>  [6/11 @ 9:15]  (4/10)

  • bridge of khaza-dum  <estel7>  [6/10 @ 18:38]  (1/3)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 3.  The blowing of the horn  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/10 @ 18:22]  (13/30)

  • Did every Elf intend to go West?  <Rwll>  [6/10 @ 15:24]  (4/6)

  • another Arwen question  <hatster>  [6/10 @ 13:50]  (11/24)

  • Bridge of Khazad-dūm  <Black numenorian>  [6/10 @ 12:05]  (14/39)

  • Chris Tolkien's books?  <Temujin>  [6/10 @ 9:54]  (1/3)

  • Fancy a Dwarfs copy of LoTR or the Sil  <Villordsutch>  [6/10 @ 5:52]  (2/3)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 2.  Faramir questions Frodo  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/10 @ 3:42]  (17/38)

  • IV.5. The Window on the West – 1.  Initial remarks  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/10 @ 3:40]  (2/5)

  • the real "Lord" of the Rings?  <Lorien-lover>  [6/9 @ 13:53]  (8/29)

  • Aerwyn  <TheSource>  [6/9 @ 10:07]  (4/6)

  • Ranger questions  <MotherWasAHamster>  [6/9 @ 7:01]  (11/24)

  • Who is the POV?  <Entish_FreedomFighter>  [6/8 @ 16:29]  (1/6)

  • Smeeegol  <precious2004>  [6/8 @ 3:57]  (3/7)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits: Chapter summary (WARNING: lengthy, bad poetry inside)  <gullygilly>  [6/7 @ 21:04]  (17/19)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #16: Open Forum  <gullygilly>  [6/7 @ 9:12]  (3/8)

  • Ringwraiths  <Lhunithiliel>  [6/7 @ 1:51]  (6/14)

  • Some Questions of Orcs...  <Entish_FreedomFighter>  [6/6 @ 19:34]  (2/6)

  • Trusting Gollum  <lotr elentari>  [6/6 @ 17:16]  (2/3)

  • Would we like this book less  <Murmuran>  [6/6 @ 14:57]  (15/20)

  • Gandalfs ring and Saruman  <Alveric>  [6/6 @ 9:42]  (1/10)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Hasenpfeffer #15: Chapter title  <gullygilly>  [6/6 @ 5:05]  (7/21)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #14: On Oliphaunts  <gullygilly>  [6/6 @ 4:40]  (8/10)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #13: Rangers & the Reality of war  <gullygilly>  [6/6 @ 4:33]  (8/10)

  • Next week's chapter discussion  <Celandine Brandybuck>  [6/6 @ 1:38]  (1/1)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #12: Faramir con't   <gullygilly>  [6/5 @ 15:04]  (9/15)

  • Question on Sauron  <Jus>  [6/5 @ 13:20]  (3/5)

  • Looking for the LoTR bible  <summertime>  [6/5 @ 7:07]  (1/12)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits Discussion #11: Faramir  <gullygilly>  [6/5 @ 3:45]  (11/16)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits  #10: Two's company; three's a crowd  <gullygilly>  [6/5 @ 3:39]  (5/9)

  • Where did Boromir get a helm?  <Linduin>  [6/4 @ 20:17]  (2/4)

  • Who are the new Inklings?  <Dryhten>  [6/4 @ 20:01]  (1/9)

  • Riders of Rohan-Does this remind you of anything?  <Ceorl>  [6/4 @ 17:06]  (8/20)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits  #9: He loves me...he loves me not...  <gullygilly>  [6/4 @ 16:56]  (14/24)

  • Now that I brought it up in my post...WERE Hobbits formerly schooled?  (No Text)  <Farawyn>  [6/4 @ 15:07]  (2/11)

  • Sam is so wrong!!!!  <Golfimbul>  [6/4 @ 10:06]  (7/11)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits  #8: 'Food is Good'  <gullygilly>  [6/4 @ 4:34]  (7/18)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits  #7: Setting the table   <gullygilly>  [6/4 @ 4:27]  (8/12)

  • Best fights in Arda History  <kodax>  [6/4 @ 2:05]  (8/15)

  • A question for you language scholars  <Marigold Gamgee>  [6/3 @ 23:37]  (2/4)

  • Something I've always been curious about...  <Anadorn of Gondor>  [6/3 @ 15:29]  (4/4)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits  #6 :This Little Light of Mine part 2  <gullygilly>  [6/3 @ 14:57]  (10/22)

  • Sauron  <Djurgarden>  [6/3 @ 12:32]  (3/17)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits  # 5: This Little Light of Mine part 1  <gullygilly>  [6/3 @ 4:29]  (9/23)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #4:  A Hostile Presence   <gullygilly>  [6/3 @ 4:22]  (11/14)

  • About the Arkenstone  <Ring's wrath>  [6/3 @ 2:40]  (1/2)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #3: Trees 'n Such  <gullygilly>  [6/2 @ 19:21]  (9/22)

  • The Black Gate is Closed summary  <Doorwarden of Theoden>  [6/2 @ 19:06]  (16/16)

  • Scouring of the Shire?  <Stasia>  [6/2 @ 18:45]  (1/5)

  • Halls of Mandos  <Scarfang>  [6/2 @ 16:22]  (2/3)

  • Shakespeare's influence on Tolkien?  <elf_wannabee>  [6/2 @ 9:15]  (3/3)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits # 2: Herbal Essence   <gullygilly>  [6/2 @ 4:33]  (8/35)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits #1: Imagery  <gullygilly>  [6/2 @ 4:14]  (9/21)

  • I'll probably recieve the dunce award for this...  <NoneOfTheAbove>  [6/2 @ 3:10]  (2/5)

  • who really is the Lord of the rings  <Nusewwen>  [6/1 @ 14:09]  (7/29)

  • Book IV Chapt. IV: Of Herbs & Stewed Rabbits-- How I'll ladle out the portions...  <gullygilly>  [6/1 @ 9:26]  (11/13)

  • Why no Giants?  <Alveric>  [6/1 @ 8:12]  (5/8)
  •