2002
2003
2004

  • why do you suppose  <arwëon>  [5/31 @ 18:06]  (7/15)

  • A Thief in the Night #2: Hi-ho, Hi-ho  <nerdanel_50>  [5/31 @ 13:01]  (10/13)

  • A Thief in the Night #1: Playing with the Big Boys  <nerdanel_50>  [5/31 @ 12:57]  (9/24)

  • A Thief in the Night: Introduction  <nerdanel_50>  [5/31 @ 12:33]  (1/1)

  • Comments on the Chronicle of Higher Ed article linked on Main  <drogo_drogo>  [5/31 @ 11:49]  (3/11)

  • Of the Sun and Moon  <Lorien-lover>  [5/31 @ 10:27]  (3/4)

  • The names of Bard and Brand...  <NZ Strider>  [5/31 @ 3:25]  (5/8)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: Summary  <Atlas>  [5/31 @ 1:59]  (12/16)

  • Question about Faramir  <Saracene>  [5/30 @ 7:26]  (4/5)

  • Whose mistake was it: Tolkien's, or Gandalf's?  <Ataahua>  [5/30 @ 0:48]  (10/31)

  • A word...  <Landalay>  [5/29 @ 22:10]  (4/7)

  • help!lplz  <elessar_king>  [5/29 @ 17:33]  (15/18)

  • Boromir Book vs. Movie Question  <Viggolicious Drooler>  [5/29 @ 3:10]  (7/31)

  • Parentage of Heroes  <Macca>  [5/28 @ 13:36]  (6/20)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #10 Open Discussion  <Atlas>  [5/28 @ 6:01]  (8/17)

  • Help me Understand.  <ElfatHeart>  [5/27 @ 21:50]  (6/58)

  • Order of reading the books?  <LyinRyan>  [5/27 @ 17:51]  (7/29)

  • Elf Children  <Rhiandra Took>  [5/27 @ 16:47]  (3/5)

  • Reading Room Header  <Suni>  [5/27 @ 16:43]  (1/2)

  • Eowyn and Faramir's Romance  <well he's back>  [5/27 @ 15:36]  (5/9)

  • THE HOBBIT  <OhMeOhMy427>  [5/27 @ 10:18]  (1/36)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #9 Then it seems we are at an impasse.  <Atlas>  [5/27 @ 3:06]  (4/4)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #8 All that is gold is not edible...  <Atlas>  [5/27 @ 3:05]  (6/10)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #7 ...and take those elves with you!  <Atlas>  [5/27 @ 1:17]  (6/14)

  • Is the thread on Tolkien & Christianity closed  <well he's back>  [5/26 @ 20:33]  (4/6)

  • Shadowfax  <Cry of the Nazgul>  [5/26 @ 16:44]  (4/5)

  • Can I just say how excited I am by The Sil sign-up thread?  <Curious>  [5/26 @ 16:40]  (12/58)

  • ** Silmarillion Discussion Sign-up Thread  <Altaira>  [5/26 @ 11:59]  (31/52)

  • The Silmirillion  <Moiratron>  [5/26 @ 5:11]  (6/9)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #6 What terms do you offer?  <Atlas>  [5/26 @ 4:35]  (6/7)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #5 Don't tread on me.  <Atlas>  [5/26 @ 4:05]  (7/7)

  • ** Reminder – Sign-up for Sil Discussion Tomorrow; Noon EST  <Altaira>  [5/25 @ 22:52]  (2/5)

  • Recently I posted about Frodo journeying to Mordor with Pippin in place of Sam.  Now the choice is up to you, and Frodo can take anyone from the Fellowship except for...  <Finrod Felagund 5>  [5/25 @ 18:57]  (3/3)

  • A question about Tolkien's portrayal of mothers  <snowdropper>  [5/25 @ 11:26]  (13/31)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #4 Money. That's what I want.  <Atlas>  [5/25 @ 3:58]  (6/8)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #3 Sending out an SOS...  <Atlas>  [5/25 @ 3:23]  (6/12)

  • Translation, please!  Anyone?  <Kili's aunt>  [5/25 @ 0:55]  (2/11)

  • Silmarillion Question  <MorgulMan >  [5/24 @ 23:26]  (3/4)

  • Who is Tom Bombadil  <CaptainoftheDunadain>  [5/24 @ 22:59]  (7/28)

  • A message to the class sent here as homework  <Kimi>  [5/24 @ 20:59]  (3/12)

  • Riddles in the Dark  <Pythia>  [5/24 @ 20:10]  (3/4)

  • Tolkien  <Burg>  [5/24 @ 19:02]  (3/17)

  • If their places were exchanged, how would Pippin have fared going to Mordor with Frodo as his guide?  <Finrod Felagund 5>  [5/24 @ 16:19]  (4/9)

  • Hobbit, The Gather of the Clouds: #2 Ding! Dong! The dragon's dead...  <Atlas>  [5/24 @ 3:40]  (9/10)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: #1 Consider the birds of the air...  <Atlas>  [5/24 @ 3:19]  (7/12)

  • Hobbit, The Gathering of the Clouds: Introduction  <Atlas>  [5/24 @ 2:53]  (2/2)

  • Why didn't Tolkien finish The Silmarillion?  <Arevanye>  [5/23 @ 22:11]  (4/28)

  • Reading about Tolkien  <Lúthien_Rising>  [5/23 @ 19:49]  (3/8)

  • Fire and Water: Summary  <Menelwyn>  [5/23 @ 14:40]  (13/13)

  • Letters  <gliselve>  [5/22 @ 22:46]  (3/9)

  • The hordes of Morgoth  <Ceorl>  [5/22 @ 5:08]  (4/13)

  • Fire and Water: Open Discussion  <Menelwyn>  [5/21 @ 20:21]  (3/23)

  • Cram follow-up  <Arquen>  [5/21 @ 19:32]  (2/6)

  • ** RR Discussion: and the winner IS.... **  <Altaira>  [5/21 @ 14:41]  (11/18)

  • What if Tolkien wasn't Catholic?  <Entwife Wandlimb>  [5/21 @ 12:38]  (16/88)

  • Fire and Water #10: Final Exam ;)  <Menelwyn>  [5/21 @ 8:37]  (3/10)

  • Fire and Water #9: End or a Beginning?  <Menelwyn>  [5/20 @ 18:28]  (4/4)

  • Fire and Water #8: Human Motives  <Menelwyn>  [5/20 @ 18:27]  (4/8)

  • Who could fly in Tolkien's legendarium?  <N.E. Brigand>  [5/20 @ 17:58]  (5/6)

  • Gondolin the Great  <smaug1>  [5/20 @ 15:49]  (2/4)

  • The Ambiguous Professor  <squire >  [5/20 @ 10:16]  (21/53)

  • Elves did not come from Middle-Earth  <bmxtrls250>  [5/20 @ 9:29]  (4/6)

  • Population Dynamics part III - Edain  <Beren IV>  [5/20 @ 2:47]  (1/4)

  • Fire and Water #7: The Debate  <Menelwyn>  [5/19 @ 18:38]  (6/6)

  • Fire and Water #6 The Black Arrow  <Menelwyn>  [5/19 @ 8:43]  (9/16)

  • Fire and Water #5: Bard and the Thrus  <Menelwyn>  [5/18 @ 20:16]  (9/16)

  • Perhaps an odd question,  <White Gull>  [5/18 @ 11:05]  (3/30)

  • Fire and Water #3: Smaug's response  <Menelwyn>  [5/18 @ 8:31]  (6/6)

  • Hate start up an old argument, but what are other people's views on the Balrogs/wings issue?  <Rhiandra Took>  [5/18 @ 6:59]  (16/98)

  • christian imagery in lotr  <aragornfan 2004>  [5/18 @ 1:52]  (12/87)

  • Courtly Love in LOTR  <Smokering>  [5/18 @ 1:24]  (12/37)

  • Fire and Water #3: A Bit on Bard  <Menelwyn>  [5/17 @ 13:57]  (11/16)

  • First Time Reader, Long-Time Movie-Lover: Théoden  <Frodo-esque>  [5/17 @ 10:16]  (22/80)

  • Fire and Water #2: Early Warnings  <Menelwyn>  [5/17 @ 8:33]  (5/15)

  • ** Voting thread for next book discussion  <Altaira>  [5/16 @ 23:22]  (39/43)

  • Did Celeborn, Elladan & Elrohir  <houndrock>  [5/16 @ 18:11]  (3/6)

  • Favourite  <Moiratron>  [5/16 @ 15:37]  (4/4)

  • Fire and Water #1: Intro and Preliminary Question  <Menelwyn>  [5/16 @ 14:05]  (14/30)

  •