2002
2003
2004

  • The Return Journey #5:  The Eagles Have Landed (And I Missed It!)  <Altaira>  [6/15 @ 22:43]  (4/4)

  • Oath taking  <2ndcreator>  [6/15 @ 19:25]  (5/34)

  • How have you ceremoniously retired a well-worn copy on LotR?  <elf_wannabee>  [6/15 @ 16:45]  (14/21)

  • I'm thinking of starting a discussion about characters left out of the movie: interested?  <Rhiandra Took>  [6/15 @ 15:21]  (7/17)

  • What happened to the Jewel?  <Mrs. Mandy Legolas>  [6/15 @ 13:08]  (1/2)

  • The Return Journey #4: The Recounting  <Altaira>  [6/15 @ 10:50]  (1/1)

  • Does Tolkien give any clues to the government of King Elessar?  <elf_wannabee>  [6/15 @ 9:08]  (5/9)

  • How was.... (relation)  <Apple Gooncha>  [6/14 @ 23:59]  (3/9)

  • The Return Journey #3:  Bilbo Wept  <Altaira>  [6/14 @ 23:34]  (5/17)

  • Elladan+Elrohir = twins?  <EldersisofMerry>  [6/14 @ 22:02]  (2/4)

  • The Return Journey #2: The Passing of Thorin Oakenshield  <Altaira>  [6/14 @ 21:06]  (8/10)

  • Did Frodo break the record?  <Lancelot>  [6/14 @ 11:52]  (3/11)

  • The Return Journey Addition  <Beren IV>  [6/14 @ 0:58]  (4/18)

  • The Return Journey #1:  The Sounds of Silence  <Altaira>  [6/14 @ 0:28]  (10/14)

  • Hobbit Timeline  <Altaira>  [6/14 @ 0:22]  (3/3)

  • **Secondary discussion schedule & leaders  <Altaira>  [6/14 @ 0:14]  (2/6)

  • The Clouds Burst:  #18 - Summary  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/13 @ 20:28]  (14/17)

  • After reading LotR and the Hobbit, what should I read?  <Rhiandra Took>  [6/13 @ 19:34]  (5/7)

  • OT: Suggestions for good fantasy books...  <canadanthony>  [6/13 @ 14:37]  (12/23)

  • Singing in Silmarillion  <Eärendil'sgirl>  [6/13 @ 0:49]  (4/8)

  • Tolkien-related books?  <Elf_Maven>  [6/12 @ 23:18]  (2/7)

  • More Tolkien?  <Apple Gooncha>  [6/12 @ 19:33]  (1/2)

  • Beowulf - Verse 1  <Grima Wormtongue>  [6/12 @ 14:51]  (3/11)

  • The Clouds Burst: #18 - Open Discussion  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/11 @ 21:47]  (4/5)

  • The Clouds Burst: #17 - Sailor’s Delight  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/11 @ 20:39]  (3/3)

  • The Clouds Burst: #16 - Heart Shall Be Bolder  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/11 @ 19:05]  (5/6)

  • Elronds' wife?  <Mrs. Mandy Legolas>  [6/11 @ 15:21]  (3/9)

  • Question about the Valar  <White Gull>  [6/11 @ 11:55]  (1/16)

  • Nature of the relationships between women and their husbands in Middle Earth  <Arwen's cousin>  [6/11 @ 9:49]  (7/21)

  • Denethor…A tragic Greek hero?  <Arwen's daughter>  [6/10 @ 23:37]  (3/20)

  • The Clouds Burst: Interjection: The Elves' chill flame  <Beren IV>  [6/10 @ 22:53]  (1/2)

  • SUGGESTIONS?  Transitoriness in Middle-earth  <akocubin>  [6/10 @ 15:42]  (7/12)

  • The Clouds Burst: #15 – Goblins, Goblins Everywhere  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/10 @ 12:43]  (4/4)

  • The Clouds Burst: #14 – “To Me!  To Me!”  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/10 @ 12:40]  (5/7)

  • The Clouds Burst: #13 – “It Was Very Terrible”  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/10 @ 12:34]  (7/14)

  • Apparently some Numenorians were allowed in Valinor  <Vironwe>  [6/10 @ 12:18]  (3/5)

  • The Clouds Burst: #12 – Mice!  Mice on Wings!  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/10 @ 12:17]  (8/10)

  • The Clouds Burst: #11 – Gandalf as Bismarck?  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/10 @ 12:14]  (5/7)

  • How old is Galadriel?  (No Text)  <Mrs. Mandy Legolas>  [6/10 @ 11:29]  (1/14)

  • A question about Numenoreans and death...  <Amycakes>  [6/9 @ 23:42]  (9/11)

  • Was the Balrog aware of the One Ring's existence?  <linkinparkelf>  [6/9 @ 21:04]  (5/29)

  • fall of Thangorodrim  <Lorien-lover>  [6/9 @ 15:11]  (3/6)

  • The Clouds Burst: #10 – Particularly Excellent Fireworks  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/9 @ 14:59]  (3/6)

  • The Clouds Burst:  #9 - Over Hill or Under Hill?  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/9 @ 14:34]  (4/12)

  • The Clouds Burst:  #8 - Old-Fashioned Language  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/9 @ 14:18]  (6/8)

  • The Clouds Burst:  #7 – Shoddy Dwarves  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/9 @ 13:57]  (4/7)

  • Treebeard as stonemason?  <Elf_Maven>  [6/8 @ 21:33]  (3/11)

  • The Clouds Burst:  #6 - Western Wind, Eastern Spur  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/8 @ 20:45]  (3/7)

  • The Clouds Burst: #5 – Polite words  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/8 @ 14:50]  (4/4)

  • The Clouds Burst: #4, or #12/3 – Cursed fractions!  <N.E. Brigand>  [6/8 @ 14:15]  (7/11)

  • orcs  <Mrs. Mandy Legolas>  [6/8 @ 13:34]  (2/7)

  • Reminder: Board policy regarding political threads  <Inferno>  [6/8 @ 1:54]  (1/9)

  • Easterlings  <rfb>  [6/7 @ 23:28]  (7/7)

  • Origin of Gandalf  <Less than Gandalf>  [6/7 @ 19:39]  (6/9)

  • Order of Wizards  <river-tawe-dweller>  [6/7 @ 14:00]  (2/2)

  • Over The Sea  <river-tawe-dweller>  [6/7 @ 13:57]  (4/5)

  • The Clouds Burst: #3 - The bewilderment of the treasure  <Altaira>  [6/7 @ 13:08]  (8/21)

  • The Clouds Burst: #2 - A likely story  <Altaira>  [6/7 @ 13:03]  (5/20)

  • The Clouds Burst: #1 - What of the Arkenstone of Thrain?  <Altaira>  [6/7 @ 12:59]  (10/19)

  • The Clouds Burst: Introduction  <Altaira>  [6/7 @ 12:55]  (1/2)

  • ** Secondary book discussion: sign-up thread  <Altaira>  [6/7 @ 12:46]  (8/21)

  • Confusion on Arwen's immortality!?!?  <Elf Maiden of Lorien>  [6/6 @ 21:49]  (3/14)

  • A Thief in the Night Afterthought: Don't be hasty  <nerdanel_50>  [6/6 @ 15:09]  (6/9)

  • Cirith Ungol "Watchers"  <river-tawe-dweller>  [6/6 @ 13:01]  (3/7)

  • A Thief in the Night: Summary  <nerdanel_50>  [6/6 @ 12:42]  (14/17)

  • Observation on Elvish lands-Lorien--Valinor  <FrodoloveIs>  [6/6 @ 12:32]  (3/14)

  • reading room index has been updated  (No Text - Link Inside)  <hatster>  [6/6 @ 9:40]  (9/17)

  • Where were the rest of the Nazgul?  <Indy3>  [6/5 @ 17:13]  (2/8)

  • just a quick question how were the black gets broken by the lat alliance  (No Text)  <mop>  [6/5 @ 7:07]  (1/10)

  • "Tolkien's Ring"  <helmsdeep-archer>  [6/4 @ 23:07]  (3/3)

  • LOTR and D&D  <helmsdeep-archer>  [6/4 @ 20:07]  (1/1)

  • A Thief in the Night #10: Open discussion  <nerdanel_50>  [6/4 @ 16:45]  (2/12)

  • Some not-very-deep thoughts on Tolkien and Homer  <Aunt Dora Baggins>  [6/4 @ 15:52]  (5/9)

  • Types of Wizards  <helmsdeep-archer>  [6/4 @ 15:29]  (3/3)

  • Boromir + Faramir  <atheist>  [6/4 @ 13:53]  (2/3)

  • A Thief in the Night #9: A Thief in the Night  <nerdanel_50>  [6/4 @ 10:04]  (7/16)

  • Two book questions  <Druid13>  [6/4 @ 8:37]  (16/23)

  • Into the West should have  been played when Frodo is leaving...I always cry when I hear it  (No Text)  <Elf Maiden of Lorien>  [6/3 @ 21:29]  (1/2)

  • Sauron  <Elf Maiden of Lorien>  [6/3 @ 20:43]  (1/4)

  • Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli are each the "Achilles" of their respective races. Discuss.  (No Text)  <Gerontius>  [6/3 @ 18:31]  (11/38)

  • does anyone knows why was given that number(3,7 and 9) of rings for each race?  <mariana>  [6/3 @ 16:30]  (4/38)

  • Reminder: Live Chat with Prof. Michael Drout, noon ET today  (No Text - Link Inside)  <Lúthien_Rising>  [6/3 @ 11:53]  (4/15)

  • A Thief in the Night #8: He's Back  <nerdanel_50>  [6/3 @ 11:39]  (10/17)

  • A Thief in the Night #7: Belt and Suspenders?  <nerdanel_50>  [6/3 @ 11:34]  (7/23)

  • tolkien quote needed  <Gûm-ishi Ashi Gurum>  [6/3 @ 11:32]  (1/23)

  • looking at the enemy's movements (very long post)  <Gentle One>  [6/3 @ 8:05]  (4/6)

  • Dwarves and Narsil  <Villordsutch>  [6/2 @ 16:42]  (4/26)

  • Anglo Saxon attitudes at Theoden’s funeral?  <Golfimbul>  [6/2 @ 14:21]  (5/12)

  • **Secondary book discussion details  <Altaira>  [6/2 @ 14:05]  (4/4)

  • A Thief in the Night #6: What Else Has It Got In Its Pocketses?  <nerdanel_50>  [6/2 @ 12:14]  (7/12)

  • A Thief in the Night #5: The Dwarves' Hobbit  <nerdanel_50>  [6/2 @ 12:12]  (8/9)

  • The movie trilogy - a "good fairy story"?  <Estelwyn>  [6/2 @ 4:25]  (10/39)

  • ** Roll Call for June discussion leaders  <Altaira>  [6/2 @ 1:20]  (4/10)

  • ** Confirmation of Silmarillion Chapters  <Altaira>  [6/2 @ 0:41]  (5/6)

  • Gandalf and the Witch King  <CaptainoftheDunadain>  [6/1 @ 23:03]  (6/11)

  • would anyone like to discuss letter #131?  <an seileachan>  [6/1 @ 21:34]  (7/14)

  • Monarchy in Middle Earth  <well he's back>  [6/1 @ 17:09]  (6/25)

  • Other suggested readings on Mr Tolkien?  <Bythedar>  [6/1 @ 14:40]  (1/9)

  • A Thief in the Night #4: Enough Rope  <nerdanel_50>  [6/1 @ 10:19]  (7/7)

  • A Thief in the Night #3: How much watch?  <nerdanel_50>  [6/1 @ 10:11]  (9/15)

  • Aragorn and athelas  <Eärendil'sgirl>  [6/1 @ 1:21]  (3/5)

  •